Quarterly Review
Published 1809-1967. Quarterly, 6s. This was the high Tory review, and the first among its competitors to be founded – before the Whig Edinburgh or the Radical Westminster. It was published by John Murray. Historian contributors included Lord Acton and J. A. Froude. (See DNCJ, where all quotations appear, for further information and references to additional sources; online edition ProQuest British Periodicals.)
“American Annals; or, a Chronological History of America from Its Discovery in 1492 to 1806.” Quarterly, 2, no. 4: (1809): 319–37.
Discusses the work of Dr. [Abiel] Holmes by summarizing key points and scrutinizing missing material, lack of sufficient information, and having too broad and unmanageable a focus. Reviewed: Holmes, Abiel. American Annals; or, a Chronological History of America from its Discovery in 1492 to 1806.
“The History of Barbadoes, from the First Discovery of the Island in the Year 1605, till the Accession of Lord Seaforth, 1801.” Quarterly, 1, no. 2: (1809): 258–68.
Briefly discusses John Poyer’s book, stating that this account is uninteresting but does not truly explore the history of the Island. The article then moves on to offer detailed information about the Island beyond governmental affairs by commenting on the slave trade and the population problems of the colonial islands of the West Indies. Reviewed: Poyer, John. The History of Barbadoes from the first discovery of the island in the year 1605, till the accession of Lord Seaforth, 1801.
“A History of the Political Life of the Right Honourable William Pitt; Including Some Account of the Times in Which He Lived.” Quarterly, 4, no. 7: (1810): 207–71.
A mixed review of Gifford’s political biography of William Pitt (1708-1778). The reviewer attacks the sources used, points out the elements of this period that have been overlooked, discusses the bias that can occur when writing history, and instructs readers as to how a political biography should be written. Reviewed: : Gifford, John. A History of the Political Life of the Right Honourable William Pitt; including some Account of the Times in which he lived.
“Ecclesiastical Biography, or Lives of Eminent Men Connected with the History of Religion in England, from the Commencement of the Reformation to the Revolution.” Quarterly, 4, no. 7: (1810): 93–103.
Examines the bibliographical scholarship of Christopher Wordsworth, which addresses the biographies of men of the English Church in the 16th and 17th century. The review focuses on how Wordsworth selected subjects and biographers. Points out the importance of respecting historical sources and the usefulness of bringing old works together in a new collection. Reviewed: Wordsworth, Christopher. Ecclesiastical Biography, or Lives of Eminent Men connected with the history of Religion in England, from the commencement of the Reformation to the Revolution.
“History of Brazil.” Quarterly, 4, no. 8: (1810): 454–74.
Examines the first volume of Robert Southey’s History of Brazil, which focuses on 16th-century events. For the most part, the reviewer praises the work. Commends Southey for his work’s demonstration of the interaction of the European settlers, both with each other and with the native population. Reviewed: Southey. Robert. History of Brazil. See also 1817 review of vol 2.
“The History, Ecclesiastical and Civil, and Survey of the Antiquities of Winchester.” Quarterly, 3, no. 6: (1810): 347–68.
A mixed review (and summary) of Rev. John Milner’s book. Observes that readers may be prejudiced by the author’s beliefs and principles; much of the evidence used is not credible or sufficient. Nevertheless this is a work unrivalled in many areas. Reviewed: Milner, John. The History, Ecclesiastical and Civil, and Survey of Antiquities of Winchester.
“A History of the Colleges, Halls, and Public Buildings Attached to the University of Oxford, Including the Lives of the Founders.” Quarterly, 6, no. 11: (1811): 87–98.
States that this work is accurate and judicious, however the author has omitted some valuable topics. Then the reviewer goes on to offer detailed discussion of content with many lengthy excerpts from the work. Reviewed: Chambers, Alexander. History of the Colleges, Halls, and Public Buildings attached to the University of Oxford, including the Lives of the Founders.
“Historical Sketches of the South of India; in an Attempt to Trace the History of Mysoor, from the Origin of the Hindoo Government of That State, to the Extinction of the Mahommedan Dynasty in 1799, &c.” Quarterly, 6, no. 11: (1811): 103–24.
Reviewer offers a lengthy detailed summary but very little opinion about the work as whole, stating that a real opinion will be given when the next and final volume is completed. Reviewed: Wilks, Lieut Col. Historical Sketches of the South of India; in an Attempt to trace the History of Mysoor, from the Origin of the Hindoo Government of that State, to the Extinction of the Mahommedan Dynasty in 1799 (1810). See entry for remaining volumes in 1817.
“History of Ancient Wiltshire.” Quarterly, 6, no. 12: (1811): 440–48.
This second notice states that the book is well-organized, well-illustrated , and discusses new subject matter with judiciousness and knowledge. Offers an in-depth look at a few of the topics in the work and states that overall it this volume as well done as its predecessor. Reviewed: : Hoarse, Sir Richard Colt. History of Ancient Wiltshire. Part II.
“The History of Ancient Wiltshire.” Quarterly, 5, no. 9: (1811): 111–20.
Review presents some of the findings in the book that can be challenged and discusses the benefits and faults of the information, illustrations and sources used. Reviewed: Hoarse, Sir Richard Colt. The History of Ancient Wiltshire.
“The History of Mauritius and the Neighbouring Islands, &c. &c.” Quarterly, 5, no. 9: (1811): 229–41.
Observes that, although the book is oddly structured, it brings together the many biographies it utilizes in a useful and beneficial manner and that it is beyond criticism. There is then a very detailed summary of the contents, which discusses the history of the Islands, their people, their exports, and the benefits of islands to the French and British. Reviewed: Viscount de Vaux, Charles Grant. The History of Mauritius and the neighbouring Islands.
“The History of the Inquisitions; Including the Secret Transactions of Those Horrific Tribunals.” Quarterly, 6, no. 12: (1811): [313]-357.
Review of three works. The anonymous History ‘will do harm rather than good, because the manufacturer of it has indiscriminately heaped together truth and falsehood’ about Catholicism and the Inquisition Reviewed: The History of the Inquisitions; including the Secret Transactions of those Horrific Tribunals (Stockdale, 1810) and two other works.
“History of the Reformation in Scotland; with an Introductory Book and an Appendix.” Quarterly, 7, no. 13: (1812): 107–20.
Comments that the author presents his work with impartiality and moral sense. But some further topics could have been included and others expanded. Reviewed: Cooke, George. History of the Reformation in Scotland; with an Introductory Book and an Appendix. (1811).
“Present State of the Spanish Colonies; Including a Particular Report of Hispaniola, or the Spanish Part of Santo Domingo; with a General Survey of the Settlements on the South Continent of America, as Relates to the History, Trade, Population, Customs, Manners, &c. with a Concise Statement of the Sentiments of the People on Their Relative Situation to The.” Quarterly, 7, no. 14: (1812): [235]-264.
Notes that this work contains too many and varied topics; fewer topics examined in more depth would have been preferable. Reviewed: Walton, William. Present State of the Spanish Colonies; including a particular Report of Hispaniola, or the Spanish Part of Santo Domingo; with a general Survey of the Settlements on the South Continent of America, as relates to the History, Trade, Population, Customs, Manners, &c. with a concise Statement of the Sentiments of the People on their relative Situation to the Mother Country. (1812).
“The History of the European Commerce with India. To Which Is Subjoined, a Review of the Arguments for and against the Trade with India, and the Management of It by a Chartered Company.” Quarterly, 7, no. 15: (1812): 114–44.
Judges that this work fills in the gaps of knowledge on this subject; it is well laid-out and overall well-done. Reviewed: Macpherson, David. The History of the European Commerce with India. To which is subjoined, a Review of the Arguments for and against the Trade with India, and the Management of it by a Chartered Company. (1812).
“History of Dissenters, from the Revolution in 1688, to the Year 1808.” Quarterly, 10, no. 19: (1813): 90–139.
The content of the three works reviewed is discussed and the similar or competing claims about related subject matter is examined. Reviewed: Bogue, James & James Bennett. History of Dissenters, from the Revolution in 1688, to the year 1808. (1812).
“The Life of John Knox, Containing Illustrations of the History of the Reformation in Scotland, with Biographical Notices of the Principal Reformers, and Sketches of the Progress of Literature in Scotland, during a Great Part of the Sixteenth Century.” Quarterly, 9, no. 18: (1813): 418–33.
Judges this work to be ample, original, and well sourced. Reviewed: McCrie, Thomas. The Life of John Knox, containing Illustrations of the History of the Reformation in Scotland, with Biographical Notices of the principal Reformers, and Sketches of the Progress of Literature in Scotland, during a great Part of the Sixteenth Century. (See later review of 1851 new edition.).
“History of the Azores, or Western Islands; Containing an Account of the Government, Laws, and Religion; the Manners, Ceremonies, and Character of the Inhabitants; and Demonstrating the Importance of These Valuable Islands to the British Empire.” Quarterly, 11, no. 21: (1814): 190–203.
An essay on exploration and discovery. Reviewed: Ashe, Thomas. History of the Azores, or Western Islands; containing an Account of the Government, Laws, and Religion; the Manners, Ceremonies, and Character of the Inhabitants; and demonstrating the Importance of these valuable Islands to the British Empire. (1813).
“An Account of the Kingdom of Caubul and Its Dependencies in Persia, Tartary, and India; Comprizing a View of the Afghaun Nation, and a History of the Doorqunee Monarchy.” Quarterly, 14, no. 27: (1815): 152–88.
Critiques another periodical for calling this work ‘distinguished’. Unfortunately the mission to Afghanistan had no expertise on antiquarian research or physical science; mostly concerned with contemporary international politics, i.e. with Russia. Reviewed: Elphinstone, Hon. Mountstuart. An Account of the Kingdom of Caubul and its Dependencies in Persia, Tartary, and India; comprizing a View of the Afghaun Nation, and a History of the Doorqunee Monarchy. 1815.
“A History of Inventions and Discoveries,.” Quarterly, 14, no. 28: (1816): 405–29.
The author’s work is scholarly and philosophical, but the translator has arranged the numerous ‘dissertations’ in a disorderly way. Reviewed: Beckmann, John. A History of Inventions and Discoveries. Trans. William Johnston. 1815.
“Symbolic Illustrations of the History of England, from the Roman Invasion to the Present Time, Accompanied with a Narrative of the Principal Events, Designed More Particularly for the Instruction of Young Persons.” Quarterly, 15, no. 30: (1816): 418–19.
Criticizes this work, and its method of teaching history through illustrations alone, as not useful and actually rather absurd. States that these illustrations need many pages of explanation in any case and that, even with the written explanations provided, this illustrative attempt at teaching history is not very effective. Reviewed: Rundall, Mary Ann. Symbolic Illustrations of the History of England, from the Roman Invasion to the present Time, accompanied with a Narrative of the Principal Events, designed more particularly for the Instruction of Young Persons. 1815.
“The History of Persia, from the Most Early Period to the Present Time: Containing an Account of the Religion, Government, Usages, and Character of the Inhabitants of That Kingdom.” Quarterly, 15, no. 29: (1816): 236–92.
Praise for the author’s ‘candour and industry’ despite ‘the appalling fables’ which make up the earlier chapters of Persian history. Reviewed: Malcolm, Col. Sir John. The History of Persia, from the most Early Period to the Present Time: containing an Account of the Religion, Government, Usages, and Character of the Inhabitants of that Kingdom.
“Historical Sketches of the South of India; in an Attempt to Trace the History of Mysoor; from the Origin of the Hindoo Government of That State to the Extinction of the Mahomedan Dynasty in 1799.” Quarterly, 18, no. 35: (1817): 47–73.
Very detailed account of India in 18th century; the author is charged with indiscretion , even calumny, in describing British officers’ behaviour. Reviewed: Wilks, Col. Mark. Historical Sketches of the South of India; in an Attempt to trace the History of Mysoor; from the Origin of the Hindoo Government of that State to the Extinction of the Mahomedan Dynasty in 1799. Vol. II/Vol. III. 1817. See also review of earlier volumes in 1811.
“The History of Brazil.” Quarterly, 18, no. 35: (1817): 99–128.
A lengthy essay on the subject-matter, with reference to Southey’s merits and defects as a historian. The subject is too vast and various for his biographical and narrative talents. Reviewed: Southey, Robert. The History of Brazil. Vol. II. See also 1810 review of Vol. 1.
“The History of Java.” Quarterly, 17, no. 33: (1817): 72–96.
Regrets that the island has remained part of the Dutch empire. Historical information thrown hastily together. Reviewed: Raffles, Thomas Stamford. The History of Java. 1817.
“The History of Small-Pox.” Quarterly, 19, no. 38: (1818): 357–75.
Includes a narrative of ancient -- and Chinese -- understandings of smallpox but the thrust of the article is contemporary public-health policy. A History of Vaccination by the same author is also reviewed and judged less admirable. Reviewed: Moore, James. The History of Small-pox.
“The Secret and True History of the Church of Scotland, from the Restoration to the Year 1678.” Quarterly, 18, no. 36: (1818): 502–41.
Not an account of history, but a collection of the materials for such an account -- ‘of a dark and turbulent period’. Reviewed: The Secret and True History of the Church of Scotland, from the Restoration to the year 1678. By the Rev. Mr James Kirkton . . . Ed from the MS by Charles Kirkpartick Sharpe. 1817.
“The History of Greece.” Quarterly, 25, no. 49: (1821): 154–74.
Despite ‘acuteness and patient investigation’, Mitford is ‘singularly deficient’ in this work. A narrative without analysis, lacking eloquence and enthusiasms. And the style is ‘obscure, inharmonious and ungrammatical’. Closes by drawing parallels between the histories of Greece and Britain. Reviewed: Mitford, William. The History of Greece. Volume 5.
“The Civil and Constitutional History of Rome, from Its Foundation to the Age of Augustus.” Quarterly, 27, no. 54: (1822): [273]-308.
Lengthy commentary which ignores the book at hand. Concludes with observation of Bankes’s deficiency with respect to investigation, reflection and style. Falls short of ‘those qualities with which we have ventured to invest the character of the genuine historian.’ Reviewed: Bankes, Henry. The Civil and Constitutional History of Rome, from its Foundation to the Age of Augustus. 1818.
“A Memoir of Central India, Including Malwa and Adjoining Provinces; with the History, and Copious Illustrations, of the Past and Present Condition of That Country.” Quarterly, 29, no. 58: (1823): 382–414.
Complacent assessment of the excellence of ‘the ruling powers in this distant and magnificent appendage to the British empire’. Malcolm’s book is praised for his extensive knowledge of contemporary conditions in India, but the work also includes historical and geographical knowledge. Reviewed: Malcolm, John. A Memoir of Central India, including Malwa and adjoining Provinces; with the History, and copious Illustrations, of the Past and Present Condition of that Country. 1823.
“Bishop Burnet’s History of His Own Time: With the Suppressed Passages of the First Volume, and Notes by the Earls of Dartmouth and Hardwicke and Speaker Onslow, Hitherto Unpublished. To Which Are Added the Cursory Remarks of Swift, and Other Observations.” Quarterly, 29, no. 57: (1823): 165–213.
This book is part of an Oxford (Clarendon Press) series of new editions of historical works. Reviewed: Burnet, Gilbert. Bishop Burnet’s History of his Own Time: with the suppressed Passages of the First Volume, and Notes by the Earls of Dartmouth and Hardwicke and Speaker Onslow, hitherto unpublished. To which are added the Cursory Remarks of Swift, and other Observations.
“History of the Peninsular War.” Quarterly, 29, no. 57: (1823): 53–85.
Reviewer expresses great pride in Englishmen’s contribution; praises Southey’s talents and experience, industry, research, style, knowledge etc. Concludes with some quibbles with respect to excessive detail. Reviewed: Southey, Robert. History of the Peninsular War. Vol. I. 1823.
Barrow, John.“The Character of the Russians, and a Detailed History of Moscow, &c.” Quarterly, 31, no. 61: (April 1824): 146–66.
Dismisses most of the book as ‘being constructed of those materials which usually make up our half-crown Guides to watering places’. Lyall is a Scottish physician and traveller. Book is not even mediocre; ‘the style is mean and vulgar’. Reviewed: Lyall, Robert. The Character of the Russians, and a detailed History of Moscow. 1823. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Arnold, Thomas.“Romische Geschichte, von B. G. Niebuhr. History of Rome.” Quarterly, 32, no. 63: (June 1825): 67–92.
Niebuhr’s book has been in print for 12 years at the time of this review, but its excellence is not well known in Britain. Admires German historical scholarship in general. Reviewed: Niebuhr, B.G. Romische Geschichte, von B. G. Niebuhr. History of Rome. 1811/1812. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Procter, George.“The History of Ancient and Modern Wines.” Quarterly, 32, no. 63: (June 1825): 232–62.
Review is focused more on the chemistry of wine, ancient and modern, than on the history of its making and use. Includes extensive excerpts and concludes with the question of whether wine-making should be attempted in England. Reviewed: Henderson, A. The History of Ancient and Modern Wines. 1825. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palgrave, Francis.“The History of England, from the Invasion of Julius Caesar to the Revolution of 1688.” Quarterly, 34, no. 67: (June 1826): 248–98.
The anonymous reviewer (Palgrave) of a new edition takes the opportunity to critique Hume’s methodology and scholarship. Reviewed: Hume, David. The History of England, from the Invasion of Julius Caesar to the Revolution of 1688. 1825. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Ellis, Henry.“The Political History of India, from 1784 to 1823.” Quarterly, 35, no. 69: (January 1827): 32–66.
Notes that Malcolm’s earlier Political Sketch of India is incorporated as the first 5 chapters of this work, which is also primarily concerned with contemporary and recent history. Also comments on two other pamphlets. Reviewed: Malcolm, John. The Political History of India, from 1784 to 1823. 1826. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Edwards, Edward.“The History of the British and Foreign Bible Society.” Quarterly, 36, no. 71: (June 1827): 1–28.
Owen’s history of the BFBS’s first twenty years is subsumed in the context of a contemporary dispute over publishing the apocryphal books of the Bible. Reviewed: Owen, John. The History of the British and Foreign Bible Society. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Blunt, J. J.“History of the Progress and Suppression of the Reformation in Italy, in the Sixteenth Century; Including a Sketch of the History of the Reformation in the Grisons.” Quarterly, 37, no. 73: (January 1828): 50–84.
A discussion of critics of the Catholic Church before Luther. Reviewed: McCrie, Thomas. History of the Progress and Suppression of the Reformation in Italy, in the Sixteenth Century; including a Sketch of the History of the Reformation in the Grisons. 1827. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Southey, Robert and Edward Edwards.“The Constitutional History of England, from the Accession of Henry VII. to the Death of George II.” Quarterly, 37, no. 73: (January 1828): 194–260.
The anonymous reviewers (Southey and Edwards) are skeptical of the notion of separating constitutional from political and other aspects of history, and more generally of Hallam’s partisanship. He is accused of misrepresentation, sophistry and special pleading. Reviewed: Hallam, Henry. The Constitutional History of England, from the Accession of Henry VII. to the Death of George II. 1827. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Southey, Robert.“Chronological History of the West Indies.” Quarterly, 38, no. 75: (July 1828): 193–241.
Review discusses the work of a Royal Navy captain, who has pulled together various chronicles to lay out what the reviewer describes as a shameful story. Concludes with comments on modern colonization in Australia. Reviewed: Southey, (Captain) Thomas. Chronological History of the West Indies. 1827. (Attribution Wellesley Index}.
Southey, Robert.“The History and Antiquities of the County Palatine of Durham.” Quarterly, 39, no. 78: (April 1829): 360–405.
Praise for local histories in general, and comments on the difficulty of writing this particular history. Reviewed: Surtees, Robert. The History and Antiquities of the County Palatine of Durham. 1816-1828. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Scott, Walter.“History of Scotland.” Quarterly, 41, no. 82: (November 1829): 328–59.
The anonymous reviewer (Walter Scott) discourses on the difficulties of writing a marketable history of Scotland and criticizes Tytler for being too hard on his predecessor Lord Hailes, while praising Tytler’s industry and competence. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland. Vol. I and II. 1829. {attribution Wellesley Index}See also review of Vol 7, 1841.
Williams, John.“Outlines of History.” Quarterly, 45, no. 90: (July 1831): 450–71.
Comments on political and historical change, with very little reference to the work ostensibly under review. Reviewed: Outlines of History. 1830. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Lockhart, J. G.“History of the War of the Succession in Spain.” Quarterly, 47, no. 94: (July 1832): 519–37.
Opens with an acknowledgement of Stanhope family involvement in the war in question; and closes with praise for the author’s skills as a historian. Also notes that manuscript correspondence has survived. Reviewed: Lord Mahon (Philip Henry Stanhope). History of the War of the Succession in Spain. 1832. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“The History of Charlemagne.” Quarterly, 48, no. 96: (December 1832): 421–55.
Discusses the period as a turning-point for Europe. Noting that the author intends this as first of a series on the great men of France, the reviewer (Milman) criticizes the concept and observes that James has written at too great length. Reviewed: James, G. P. R. The History of Charlemagne. 1832. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Croker, J. W.“History of the Revolution in England in 1688.” Quarterly, 51, no. 102: (June 1834): 493–536.
Postpones consideration of the author as ‘a mere historian and speculative moralist’ in favour of comparing the revolutions of 1638 and 1832. A footnote mentions that Mackintosh is deceased and the volume was continued by a colleague. The latter has written an unsatisfactory biographical sketch. Reviewed: Mackintosh, James. History of the Revolution in England in 1688. 1834. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Vivian, George.“A History of Architecture.” Quarterly, 53, no. 106: (April 1835): 338–71.
Observes that the gentry should show more interest in the subject. The author is described as laborious and accomplished. Reviewed: Hope, Thomas. A History of Architecture. 1835.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Egerton, Francis and H. H. Milman.“History of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries, Illustrated by Original Documents.” Quarterly, 54, no. 107: (July 1835): 78–108.
Comments on the author’s other work, and on the difficulties of working with undigested primary documents. Praise for von Raumer’s ‘impartial and scrutinizing spirit’. Reviewed: von Raumer, Fredric. History of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries, illustrated by original documents. trans. Lord Francis Egerton. 1835. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Croker, J. W. and George Murray.“History of the War in the Peninsula and the South of France, from the Year 1807 to the Year 1814.” Quarterly, 56, no. 111: (April 1836): 131–219.
First of four reviews of this work (now 4 vol.) although first volume appeared 8 years ago Compares this work favourably to ‘literary productions of a lighter and more ephemeral nature. The stream of historical knowledge belongs to posterity as well as to the existing generation, and it is one amongst the many important duties of criticism to watch with especial care against its pollution at the fountain-head.’ Expresses concern over various judgments on Napier’s part. Reviewed: Napier, W.F.P. History of the War in the Peninsula and the South of France, from the Year 1807 to the Year 1814. 1828-1834.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Murray, George and J. W. Croker.“History of the War in the Peninsula, &c.” Quarterly, 56, no. 112: (June 1836): 437–89.
Second article, here commenting on the third volume of the 4-volume work. Continues critique in terms of party bias, partiality to the French and against the Spaniards, and distortion of facts. Reviewed: Napier, W.F.P. History of the War in the Peninsula. 1835. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Lockhart, J. G.“History of England from the Peace of Utrecht to the Peace of Aix-La-Chapelle.” Quarterly, 57, no. 114: (December 1836): 330–49.
Asserts that the subject is ‘the most instructive and interesting chapter in that of the human race’. Examines and reviews Lord Mahon’s (Philip Henry Stanhope’s) 1836 work (eventually titled: History of England from the Peace of Utrecht to the Peace of Versailles). Discusses the content of the work, its merits and the sources used, and offers an overall evaluation. Reviewed: Lord Mahon. History of England from the Peace of Utrecht to the Peace of Aix-la-Chapelle. vol. I. 1836. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Murray, George and J. W. Croker.“Napier’s History of the War in the Peninsula.” Quarterly, 57, no. 114: (December 1836): 492–542.
Third article on Napier’s book; includes the recently appeared 5th volume. That volume includes an ‘Answer to Some Attacks in the Quarterly Review’, which the reviewers characterize in terms of ‘flippancy, want of temper and, above all, want of candour’. Reviewed: Napier, W.F.P. Napier’s History of the War in the Peninsula. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Murray, George and J. W. Croker.“History of the War in the Peninsula, &c.” Quarterly, 61, no. 121: (January 1838): 51–96.
Fourth article, which continues the critique and insists it is important not to abandon the task. Reviewed: Napier, William. History of the War in the Peninsula. article IV. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
“Oaths; Their Origin, Nature, and History.” Quarterly, 61, no. 122: (April 1838): 390–425.
Moderate review: author is ‘good and conscientious’ but does not offer anything new, and the historical sketch is incomplete. Reviewed: Tyler, James Endell. Oaths; their Origin, Nature, and History. 1834. (No attribution in Wellesley Index).
Croker, J. W.“Secret History of the Court of England from the Accession of George III. to the Death of George IV.; Including, amongst Other Important Matters, Full Particulars of the Mysterious Death of the Princess Charlotte.” Quarterly, 61, no. 122: (April 1838): 425–27.
‘We notice another infamous publication’ -- not by the lady of rank whose name is on the title page, but by ‘an anonymous slanderer’ who ‘imputes his wretched libels’ to her. Reviewed: Hamilton, Lady Anne [sic]. Secret History of the Court of England from the Accession of George III. to the Death of George IV.; including, amongst other important Matters, full Particulars of the Mysterious Death of the Princess Charlotte. 1832[?]. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Tytler, Patrick Fraser.“Contributions to Modern History. From the British Museum and the State Paper Office.” Quarterly, 62, no. 124: (October 1838): 452–75.
While celebrating the value of research in the private papers of great men, the reviewer decries the waste of taxpayers’ money on the publication of the Rolls Series and other government papers. The work under review is described as ‘a failure’. Reviewed: von Raumer, Fredrick. Contributions to Modern History. From the British Museum and the State Paper Office. 1836.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Blunt, J. J.“The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.” Quarterly, 62, no. 124: (October 1838): 360–85.
This new edition of Gibbon includes notes by the historian the Rev. H. H. Milman, whose objective has been to correct the ‘defect’ of Gibbon’s ‘infidel principles’ which have undoubtedly unsettled numerous immature minds. The anonymous reviewer (Blunt) thinks that a preliminary essay might have worked better than notes, but are glad to have a safe edition of Gibbon in circulation. Reviewed: Gibbon, Edward. The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. vol I-IV. 1838. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Lockhart, J. G.“History of England from the Peace of Utrecht to the Peace of Aix-La-Chapelle.” Quarterly, 63, no. 125: (January 1839): 151–65.
Subsequent volumes continue the excellence identified in reviewing the first volume, in December 1836. The author shows ‘courage, judgment, and taste . . . so as to give his narrative the picturesqueness of a Memoir, without sacrificing one jot of the real dignity of History.’ Reviewed: Lord Mahon. History of England from the Peace of Utrecht to the Peace of Aix-la-Chapelle. vol. II. 1837. vol. III. 1838.attribution Wellesley Index}.
Ford, Richard.“History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella the Catholic of Spain.” Quarterly, 64, no. 127: (June 1839): 1–58.
Observes that the subject has been hitherto neglected; welcomes the contribution of an American author to English literature. Reviewed: Prescott, William. History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella the Catholic of Spain. 1838. attribution Wellesley Index}.
Burgon, J. W.“England under the Reigns of Edward VI. and Mary, with the Contemporary History of Europe, Illustrated in a Series of Original Letters Never before Printed. With Historical Introductions, and Biographical and Critical Notes.” Quarterly, 65, no. 129: (December 1839): 52–76.
Comments on the ‘indistinctness’ common to much historical writing in comparison to the value of archival research. Tytler has pulled together original documents. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. England under the Reigns of Edward VI. and Mary, with the contemporary History of Europe, illustrated in a series of Original Letters never before printed. With Historical Introductions, and Biographical and Critical Notes. 1839. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Stanhope, Philip Henry.“History of Scotland.” Quarterly, 67, no. 134: (1841): [303]-344.
Reviewer observes that the skills of historical research are seldom found alongside those of analysis. But Tytler shows deep research and sound judgment, with ‘a narrative clear, vigorous, and graphic in its style, accurate and trustworthy in its statements.’ But Stanhope disagrees with Tytler’s reserved opinion about Mary Queen of Scots. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland. vol. VII. 1840. See also review of vols. 1-2, 1829. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Herschel, John F. W.“History of the Inductive Sciences from the Earliest to the Present Times.” Quarterly, 68, no. 135: (June 1841): 177–238.
Comments on the history and philosophy of science and admires Whewell’s work. Reviewed: Whewell, William. History of the Inductive Sciences from the Earliest to the Present Times. 1837. attribution Wellesley Index}.
Lockhart, J. G.“History of the Orders of Knighthood of the British Empire; and an Account of the Medals, Crosses, and Clasps Conferred for Naval and Military Services; with a History of the Order of the Guelphs of Hanover.” Quarterly, 68, no. 136: (September 1841): 413–44.
Describes this as the first comprehensive history of its subject, ‘elaborately prepared and splendidly printed’. Reviewed: Nicolas, Harris. History of the Orders of Knighthood of the British Empire; and an Account of the Medals, Crosses, and Clasps conferred for Naval and Military Services; with a History of the Order of the Guelphs of Hanover. 1839-1840. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“The History of India.” Quarterly, 68, no. 136: (September 1841): 377–413.
The reviewer (historian of Greece H. H. Milman) comments on the need for a brief work and characterizes Elphinstone’s research as ‘profound without being ostentatious.’ Reviewed: Elphinstone, Mountstuart. The History of India. 1841. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“History of the Conquest of Mexico, with a Preliminary View of the Ancient Mexican Civilization, and the Life of the Conqueror, Hernando Cortes.” Quarterly, 73, no. 145: (December 1843): 187–235.
Praise for the author’s skills as a historian and archival researcher (noting that Prescott’s style has fewer jarring Americanisms than formerly). Reviewed: Prescott, William H. History of the Conquest of Mexico, with a Preliminary View of the Ancient Mexican Civilization, and the Life of the Conqueror, Hernando Cortes. 1843. attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gleig, G. R.“Military Miscellany; Comprehending a History of the Recruiting of the Army, Military Punishments, &c. &c.” Quarterly, 76, no. 152: (September 1845): 387–424.
The Wellesley Index to Victorian Periodicals tells us that the reviewer is G. R. Glieg; author of one of the three works reviewed under this heading. He judges his own work to be ‘more successful than in several of [Gleig’s] preceding performances -- writing with a love and an intimate knowledge of his subject, he condenses clearly, and now and then expatiates with happy energy.’ Having dispatched all three works briefly, Glieg spends the remainder of his 38 pages on the subject of moral discipline of the British Army. Reviewed: Marshall, Henry. Military Miscellany; comprehending a History of the Recruiting of the Army, Military Punishments. 1845. With A Sketch of the Military History of Great Britain, by the Rev. G. R. Gleig, Principal Chaplain to the Forces. 1844. And A view of the Formation, Discipline, and Economy of Armies, by the late Robert Jackson. 1845. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gladstone, W. E.“History of the Church in Scotland.” Quarterly, 77, no. 153: (December 1845): 220–52.
The anonymous reviewer is Gladstone in his Peelite cabinet minister days. A witty and engaged discourse on the subject, with little attention to the works ostensibly under review. Reviewed: Russell, Rev M. History of the Church in Scotland and several other works. . {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Denman, Thomas.“History of the House of Commons from the Convention Parliament of 1688-9 to the Passing of the Reform Bill in 1832.” Quarterly, 77, no. 153: (December 1845): 192–215.
The work is a collection of biographical notices of MPs. The author’s judgment is ‘candid and dispassionate’, though the reviewer regrets so much attention to lawyers and so little to recent history. Reviewed: Townsend, W. Charles. History of the House of Commons from the Convention Parliament of 1688-9 to the passing of the Reform Bill in 1832. 1843. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“A History of Greece: 1. Legendary Greece; 2. Grecian History to the Reign of Peisistratus at Athens.” Quarterly, 78, no. 155: (June 1846): 113–44.
The anonymous reviewer is the historian H. H. Milman. He compares British scholarship on Greece favourably with that of Germany. Admires Grote’s scholarship, especially his clarification of the differences between myth and history. Extensive excerpts. Reviewed: Grote, George. A History of Greece: 1. Legendary Greece; 2. Grecian History to the Reign of Peisistratus at Athens. 1846.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Donaldson, John William.“AEgyptens Stelle in Der Weltgeschichte, &c.-Egypt’s Place in the History of the World: An Historical Treatise, in Five Books.” Quarterly, 78, no. 155: (June 1846): 145–74.
Praise for the scholarship of the Prussian ambassador. Reviewed: Bunsen, Christian Charles Josias. AEgyptens Stelle in der Weltgeschichte, &c.-Egypt’s Place in the History of the World: an Historical Treatise, in five books. vol. i-iii. Hamburg, 1845. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Eastlake, Elizabeth.“British Costume. A Complete History of the Dress of the Inhabitants of the British Islands.” Quarterly, 79, no. 158: (March 1847): 372–99.
The anonymous reviewer, frequent QR contributor Lady Eastlake, writes in a masculine voice to critique the vagaries of men’s clothing. Reviewed: Planche, J.R. British Costume. A complete History of the Dress of the Inhabitants of the British Islands. 1847. attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“History of the Conquest of Peru.” Quarterly, 81, no. 162: (September 1847): [316]-350.
In Prescott’s works, ‘the most laborious and dispassionate inquiry, instead of chilling down the history into a cold and unstirring chronicle, actually kindles it into a strange romance; fiction is pale and spiritless before the marvellous truth’. The anonymous reviewer (Milman) discusses the effect of Prescott’s visual disability on his authorship, including his explanation in this book. Reviewed: Prescott, William H. History of the Conquest of Peru. 1847. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Croker, J. W.“Outlines of the History of Ireland.” Quarterly, 83, no. 166: (September 1848): 584–614.
The essay discusses the subject extensively, making no mention of the book ostensibly under review, which was probably an anonymous school history: Outlines of the History of Ireland for Schools and Families from the earliest period to the Union in 1800, with questions for examination, and Illustrations on wood. Published in Dublin by William Curry Jr. & Co. Reviewed: Outlines of the History of Ireland.. Dublin, 1847.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gladstone, W. E.“Presbytery Examined: An Essay, Critical and Historical, on the Ecclesiastical History of Scotland since the Reformation.” Quarterly, 84, no. 167: (December 1848): 78–105.
‘Every peer who employs the opportunities furnished by his high position, together with his natural gifts, in conscientious labour for the public good, is now more than ever an ornament and a bulwark to the State, and a blessing to the people.’ Reserves the right to criticize the Duke’s views, which are nevertheless far sounder than those of Dr Arnold. Reviewed: Duke of Argyll. Presbytery examined: an Essay, Critical and Historical, on the Ecclesiastical History of Scotland since the Reformation. 1848. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Croker, J. W.“The History of England from the Accession of James II.” Quarterly, 84, no. 168: (March 1849): 549–630.
The Quarterly’s famous, scathing Croker review of Macaulay’s two volumes on the Glorious Revolution. ‘Mr Macaulay’s historical narrative is poisoned with a rancour more violent than even the passions of the time; and the literary qualities of the work, though in some respects very remarkable, are far from redeeming its substantial defects. There is hardly a page . . . that does not contain something objectionable . . . and the whole of the . . . narrative is . . . impregnated to a really marvellous degree with bad taste, bad feeling, and . . . bad faith.’ Reviewed: Macaulay, Thomas Babington. The History of England from the Accession of James II. 1849.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Stanley, A. P.“History of Greece.” Quarterly, 86, no. 172: (March 1850): 384–415.
Praise for Grote’s achievement; ‘a stately and heart-stirring narrative of the deeds of living men’. The reviewer (Stanley) expresses pride in recent English successes in history-writing. Reviewed: Grote, George. History of Greece. vol. III-VIII. 1847-1850. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Reeve, Henry.“Memoirs of the House of Brandenburg and History of Prussia during the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries.” Quarterly, 86, no. 172: (March 1850): 337–63.
The anonymous reviewer (the politician and journalist Henry Reeve) admires Ranke’s archival method (‘the greatest conquest of modern literature over the jealousy of politics’). On the other hand, the method does not help the author’s fragmentary style. Translated by: Alexander and Lady Duff Gordon. Reviewed: Ranke, Leopold. Memoirs of the House of Brandenburg and History of Prussia during the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. 1849. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gisborne, Thomas.“The History of Agriculture in Ancient, Medioeval, and Modern Times.” Quarterly, 87, no. 173: (June 1850): 141–89.
An essay on the subject, with glancing references to Hoskyns’s book. Critique of ‘mild moralizing’ and ‘irrelevant’ passages; suggests the author borrowed without attribution from Dickson. Reviewed: Hoskyns, Chandos Wren. The History of Agriculture in Ancient, Medioeval, and Modern Times. 1849. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Stanley, A. P.“History of Greece.” Quarterly, 88, no. 175: (December 1850): 41–69.
Concentrates on Grote’s fine coverage of Socrates. Continues from comments in previous (March) number. Reviewed: Grote, George. History of Greece. vol. vii-viii. 1850. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Holland, Henry.“A History of the Romans under the Empire.” Quarterly, 88, no. 176: (March 1851): 385–416.
Merivale’s book attempts to fill the void of Roman history before Gibbon’s coverage. These two volumes ‘a fair foundation for the whole work’, but ‘there is . . . a certain turgescence of phrase.’ Reviewed: Merivale, Charles. A History of the Romans under the Empire. 1850. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Innes, Cosmo.“The History of the Reformation in Scotland by John Knox.” Quarterly, 89, no. 177: (June 1851): 33–56.
Praise for a much-needed new edition, whose margins are not ‘disfigured . . . with controversy.’ Reviewed: The History of the Reformation in Scotland by John Knox. ed. David Laing. 1848. Attribution Wellesley Index. (See earlier review of 1813 edition.).
Cheney, Edward and R. H. Cheney.“History of the Church of Rome to the End of the Episcopale of Damasus, A.D. 384.” Quarterly, 89, no. 178: (September 1851): 451–91.
Context is the ‘papal aggression’ and the article (none of the books ostensibly under review is mentioned) is sharply critical of the power of the papacy throughout Europe. Reviewed (among 8 works): Shepherd, E.J. History of the Church of Rome to the end of the Episcopale of Damasus, A.D. 384. 1851. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Bushby, Henry Jeffreys.“The History of British India, from 1805 to 1835.” Quarterly, 89, no. 178: (September 1851): 257–76.
An essay on the practice of suttee, and Major Ludlow’s campaign to abolish it. No mention of the book by Wilson ostensibly under review. Reviewed: Wilson, Horace Hayman. The History of British India, from 1805 to 1835. vol.III. 1848. Attribution Wellesley Index.
O’Sullivan, Mortimer.“A Primer of the History of the Holy Catholic Church in Ireland, from the Introduction of Christianity to the Formation of the Modern Irish Branch of the Church of Rome.” Quarterly, 91, no. 181: (June 1852): 37–72.
Context is the contemporary expectation of the decline of Catholicism in Ireland. Reviewed: King, Rev. R. A Primer of the History of the Holy Catholic Church in Ireland, from the Introduction of Christianity to the Formation of the Modern Irish Branch of the Church of Rome. 3rd ed. 1851. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Colton, D. T.“The History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace, 1816-46.” Quarterly, 91, no. 181: (June 1852): 160–95.
Two works of contemporary history are considered. Both are condemned for partisanship, errors and animosities. Reviewed: Martineau, Harriet. The History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace, 1816-46. 1851. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Maitland, S. R.“History of the Ancient Barony of Castle Combe in the County of Wilts, Chiefly Compiled from Original MSS.--with Memoirs of the Families of Dunstanville, Badlesmere, Tiptoft. Scorpe, Fastolf, &c.” Quarterly, 92, no. 184: (March 1853): 275–305.
The heading of this review says the book is ‘not published’ , which apparently means that it was printed for private circulation. Neverthless the reviewer (the historian S. R. Maitland) treats it to a full public review. Reviewed: Scrope, George Poulett. History of the Ancient Barony of Castle Combe in the County of Wilts, chiefly compiled from original MSS.--with Memoirs of the Families of Dunstanville, Badlesmere, Tiptoft. Scorpe, Fastolf. 1852. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Robertson James Craigie.“The History of the Church of Rome to the End of the Episcopate of Damasus, A.D. 384.” Quarterly, 93, no. 185: (June 1853): 83–116.
Despite Shepherd’s ‘ability and learning,’ the results of his research are described as ‘rather startling’. Many documents trusted by other scholars are here called forgeries. Reviewed: Shephard, E.J. The History of the Church of Rome to the End of the Episcopate of Damasus, A.D. 384. 1851. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Freeman, E. A.“The Lives of the Queens of England, &c.” Quarterly, VOLUME 95, JUNE, 1854: (1854): 207–49.
Here Freeman uses his authorial anonymity to discuss Queen Elizabeth (a very ‘national’ sovereign), her personal life, and her ‘favourites’. As for Strickland, her style and intellect are found wanting, and she is judged inaccurate and partial; nevertheless her work is valuable to serious historical students because it contains copious extracts from little-known primary sources. Reviewed: Agnes Strickland, Lives of the Queens of England. Vols 6 and 7. 1843, and other works. Attribution Wellesley Review; picked up for HBooks by contributor search.
Stanley, A. P.“History of Latin Christianity; Including That of the Popes to the Pontificate of Nicolas V.” Quarterly, 95, no. 189: (June 1854): 38–70.
Moderate praise for this book by the Dean of St Paul’s Cathedral. But there is ‘a certain monotony of sentiment’ and ‘an abruptness and carelessness of composition’. Reviewed: Milman, Henry Hart. History of Latin Christianity; including that of the Popes to the Pontificate of Nicolas V. Vol. I, II, III. 1854.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gibson, William Sydney.“The Bell: Its Origin, History, and Uses.” Quarterly, 95, no. 190: (September 1854): 308–37.
Am essay on the subject of the books under review. Reviewed: Gatty, Rev. Alfred. The Bell: its Origin, History, and Uses. 1848. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Bunbury, E. H.“An Inquiry into the Credibility of the Early Roman History.” Quarterly, 98, no. 196: (March 1856): 321–52.
Acknowledges the influence of Niebuhr on the field, and engages with Lewis’s skepticism with respect to trustworthy evidence for this ancient period. Reviewed: Lewis, Sir George Cornewall. An Inquiry into the Credibility of the Early Roman History. 1855. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Smith, William.“A History of Greece.” Quarterly, 99, no. 197: (June 1856): 60–105.
Commentary and praise for the full 12-volume work. Observes that Grote is qualified by his personal knowledge of political and business life (something lacking in the work of ‘the most learned Germans’); Reviewed: Grote, George. A History of Greece. 1846-1856. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
James, Thomas.“The History and Antiquities of the County of Northampton.” Quarterly, 101, no. 201: (January 1857): 1–56.
Discusses ten works on the county, beginning with praise for local history: ‘If we want a boy to know some day the families of the Herods and the Caesars, let him start by learning who was his own grandfather.’ Mentions the role of subscription publishing in the support of local history. Reviewed: Baker, George. The History and Antiquities of the County of Northampton. Part I-V. 1822-1841. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Kennedy, John Pitt.“History of the Irish Poor-Law in Connexion with the Condition of the People.” Quarterly, 102, no. 203: (July 1857): 59–88.
Describes the book as a ‘very important work’ while addressing the subject independently. Reviewed: Nicholls, Sir George. History of the Irish Poor-Law in connexion with the condition of the People. 1856. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Ford, Richard.“The Book of Rugby School, Its History, and Its Daily Life.” Quarterly, 102, no. 204: (October 1857): 330–54.
The author of The Book of Rugby School (Edward Meyrick Goulburn, Arnold’s successor as headmaster) is mentioned in the text. After a lengthy discourse on the school, the reviewer (Ford) turns to the novel: ‘This attractive and suggestive book is singularly free from all sickly sentimentalism.’ Reviewed: The Book of Rugby School, its History, and its Daily Life. 1856; also Tom Brown’s School Days, 1857. No author’s name given. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Smiles, Samuel.“A Comprehensive History of the Iron Trade.” Quarterly, 104, no. 207: (July 1858): 75–106.
Seven works are reviewed, in a celebration of Britain’s contributions to the industry. Reviewed: Scrivenor, Harry. A Comprehensive History of the Iron Trade. 1841. attribution Wellesley Index}.
Pollock, W. Frederick.“History of Civilization in England.” Quarterly, 104, no. 207: (July 1858): 38–74.
The reviewer, Pollock, is a Tory politician and mathematician. He debunks Buckle’s manifesto for conceptualizing history as a science, governed by laws. Reviewed: Buckle, Henry Thomas. History of Civilization in England. vol. I. 1857. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Pollock, W. Frederick.“History of Friedrich II. of Prussia, Called Frederick the Great.” Quarterly, 105, no. 210: (April 1859): 275–304.
Addresses the second edition, commenting on the interest inspired by the subject, but noting that ‘future portions of the biography’ have yet to appear. Judges this to be Carlyle’s ‘worst work’, on grounds of the author’s notorious style. Compares Carlyle to the Pre-Raphaelites. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Bernard, Montague.“Ancient Law: Its Connection with the Early History of Society and Its Relation to Modern Ideas.” Quarterly, 110, no. 219: (July 1861): 114–38.
The book is judged an innovative and important work by a distinguished jurist. Reviewed: Maine, Henry Sumner. Ancient Law: its Connection with the Early History of Society and its Relation to Modern Ideas. 1861. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Moule, Frederick J.“Hutchins’s History of Dorset.” Quarterly, 3, no. 222: (April 1862): 281–318.
Essay covers seven works on Dorset. That of Hutchins is a re-issue, praised for ‘laborious collection of detail of it’. Reviewed: Hutchins’s History of Dorset. Part I and II. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Michell, T.“History of the Russian Empire.” Quarterly, 113, no. 225: (January 1863): 60–95.
Laments the state of Russian historiography, in a discussion of 12 works, some in Russian, some in French, as well as several in English. Reviewed: Karamzin, A. History of the Russian Empire. St Petersburg, 1842. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Milman, H. H.“History of England.” Quarterly, 114, no. 228: (October 1863): 510–37.
These are described as ‘remarkable volumes, which shed new light . . . on that most important and critical epoch in the history of the world’. The style is excellent, with ‘singularly perspicuous English’ though the mode of composition is faulty (documentary evidence is provided in the text); but Froude’s judgment of the Queen is severe. Reviewed: Froude, James Anthony. History of England. Reign of Elizabeth. vol. 1 &2. 1863. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Davies, James.“An Essay on the History of the English Government and Constitution, from the Reign of Henry VII.” Quarterly, 117, no. 234: (April 1865): 540–74.
This is a new edition (with new preface) of Russell’s youthful work on the British Constitution, issued ‘on the eve of a dissolution’. Reviewer feels the time has not yet come for a history of the 1832 Reform crisis, but admits that some such manifesto has been needed. Reviewed: Russell, John (Earl Russell). An Essay on the History of the English Government and Constitution, from the Reign of Henry VII. 1865. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Merivale, Herman.“History of Frederic the Second of Prussia, Called Frederic the Great.” Quarterly, 118, no. 235: (July 1865): 225–54.
Comments on the extensive criticism (both positive and negative) of earlier volumes, concluding that ‘we shall not profane the great work before us by the slight handling of an ordinary review.’ Reviewed: Carlyle, Thomas. History of Frederic the Second of Prussia, called Frederic the Great. Vol. V & VI. 1825. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Elwin, Whitwell.“A History of Architecture in All Countries from the Earliest Times to the Present Day.” Quarterly, 120, no. 240: (October 1866): 425–61.
Comments that this book (the first of three volumes) is ‘the first in which the subject has been properly treated.’ Reviewed: Fergusson, James. A History of Architecture in all Countries from the earliest Times to the present Day. 1865.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Howson, J. S.“The History and Antiquities of the Counties of Westmorland and Cumberland.” Quarterly, 122, no. 244: (April 1867): 347–81.
Covers 10 works on the localities -- of which only a couple of small handbooks are very recent. In the reviewer’s (Howson’s) opinion the two counties should not be considered separately. Reviewed: Nicholson, J.N & Richard Burn. The History and Antiquities of the Counties of Westmorland and Cumberland. 1777. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Herbert, H. H. M.“The History of the Norman Conquest of England, Its Causes and Its Results.” Quarterly, 123, no. 245: (July 1867): 144–73.
Praise for Freeman’s ‘fairness and honesty of purpose’, despite ‘obvious prepossessions on particular subjects’ (notably spelling). Reviewed: Freeman, Edward A. The History of the Norman Conquest of England, its Causes and its Results. Vol. I. 1867. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Stigand, William.“History of Lace.” Quarterly, 125, no. 249: (July 1868): 166–88.
Praise and admiration. for ‘a worthy historian’ of ‘this graceful ornament of civilization’. Reviewed: Palliser, Mrs. (Fanny) Bury. History of Lace. 1865. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Stigand, William.“The Massacre of St. Bartholomew, Preceded by a History of the Religious Wars in the Reign of Charles IX.” Quarterly, 126, no. 252: (April 1869): 499–534.
Covers several works on Protestantism in France. Reviewed: White, Henry. The Massacre of St. Bartholomew, preceded by a History of the Religious Wars in the Reign of Charles IX. 1868. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Burrows, Montagu.“History of England, Comprising the Reign of Queen Anne until the Peace of Utrecht.” Quarterly, 129, no. 257: (1870): 1–39.
Regrets that Macaulay did not live to write the history of the period, but engages with Mahon’s ‘less dazzling’ but ‘most trustworthy’ approach. Reviewed: Earl (Philip Henry) Stanhope. History of England, comprising the Reign of Queen Anne until the Peace of Utrecht. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Bryce, James.“History of European Morals from Augustus to Charlemagne.” Quarterly, 128, no. 255: (January 1870): 49–81.
Identifies the subject as standing between the history of speculative philosophy and that of politics. The style is ‘easy and agreeable, albeit somewhat feminine’; whereas the author’s mind is quick but too facile in generalization. He lacks, however, ‘the strength and precision of thought, force of imagination, accuracy . . . critical discrimination, [and] sobriety of judgment’ of the true historian. Reviewed: Lecky, W.E.H. History of European Morals from Augustus to Charlemagne. 1869. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Porter, Josias Leslie.“A General View of the History of the English Bible.” Quarterly, 128, no. 256: (April 1870): 301–42.
Praise for Westcott’s work and a discussion of the subject. Reviewed: Westcott, Brooke Foss. A General View of the History of the English Bible. 1868. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Burrows, Montagu.“History of England from the Fall of Wolsey to the Defeat of the Spanish Armada.” Quarterly, 128, no. 256: (April 1870): 506–44.
Discusses this with other works on Elizabeth and Mary Queen of Scots. Froude’s ‘is the most bitter, the most vehement, and at the same time the most circumstantial attack ever made on the memory of Mary Stuart.’ Terminology includes ‘hallucinations’, ‘blindfold’, and ‘a grand opportunity misused’. Readability is not everything. Reviewed: Froude, James Anthony. History of England from the Fall of Wolsey to the Defeat of the Spanish Armada. vol. IX, X, XI, XII. 1869.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Ward, Adolphus W.“Geschichte Der Revolutionszeit von 1789 Bis 1795. Von Heinrich von Sybel.” Quarterly, VOLUME 129, OCTOBER, 1870: (October 1870): 454–84.
High praise from Ward for German historiography. (This review of Von Sybel’s important work on the French Revolution was not captured by the HiPPo research methodology. It includes the English translation of the 3rd edition (by Walter C. Perry) published in London 1867-70.) 3 vol. Dusseldorf, 1865-6. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Palgrave, Francis Turner.“The Life of John Milton, Narrated in Connexion with the Political, Ecclesiastical and Literary History of His Time.” Quarterly, 132, no. 264: (April 1872): 393–423.
Finds some ‘rather serious faults’ and ‘defects’ which might be helpful to the author in completing this lengthy work; the history has become more prominent than the biography. Comments on the problems of reviewing a book published by instalments. Reviewed: Masson, David. The Life of John Milton, narrated in Connexion with the Political, Ecclesiastical and Literary History of his Time. vol. I and II. 1871. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palgrave, R. H. I.“History of British Commerce, and of the Economic Progress of the British Nation, 1763-1870.” Quarterly, 134, no. 267: (January 1873): 204–25.
The time is apt; the book is well-researched and accurate. Reviewed: Levi, Leone. History of British Commerce, and of the Economic Progress of the British Nation, 1763-1870. 1872. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Yule, Henry.“History of Bokhara, from the Earliest Period down to the Present.” Quarterly, 134, no. 268: (April 1873): 516–52.
Discussed with six other books, Vambery’s is the only work on this subject; the narrative is strong and the proportions are good. New sources are used, and the translation is judged excellent, though anonymous. Reviewed: Vambery, Arminius. History of Bokhara, from the Earliest Period down to the Present. 1873. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Shairp, J. C.“Chronicles of the Picts, Chronicles of the Scots, and Early Memorials of Scottish History.” Quarterly, 135, no. 269: (July 1873): 68–98.
Considers 12 related works Reviewed: Chronicles of the Picts, Chronicles of the Scots, and Early Memorials of Scottish History. ed. William F. Skene. 1867. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Stanley, A. P.“History of the Church of France.” Quarterly, 135, no. 269: (July 1873): 40–68.
Disagrees with Jervis on some counts, but notes he has studied the subject thoroughly, in original sources. Reviewed: Jervis, Rev. W. Henley. History of the Church of France. 2 vol. 1872. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Venables, Edmond.“The History of the Isle of Wight.” Quarterly, 137, no. 273: (1874): 1–39.
None of the 7 works discussed has been published recently. Reviewed: Worsley, Sir Richard. The History of the Isle of Wight. 1781. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Buchanan, T. R.“Worthies of All Souls; Four Centuries of English History Illustrated from the College Archives.” Quarterly, 137, no. 274: (October 1874): 514–26.
The reviewer ‘warns the historical student against expecting much’ -- they would have liked more of All Souls and less of English History. Burrows doesn’t understand the Renaissance. Reviewed: Burrows, Montagu. Worthies of All Souls; Four Centuries of English History illustrated from the College Archives. 1874.. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palgrave, William Gifford.“History of Jamaica.” Quarterly, 139, no. 277: (July 1875): 40–77.
Regrets the many stereotypes surrounding Jamaica. Critiques the author, an LMS missionary, for employing the tone of a partisan, rather than that of a historian, engaging in ‘sacerdotal spite’. Reviewed: Gardner, W.J. History of Jamaica. 1873. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Brewer, J. S.“A Short History of the English People.” Quarterly, 141, no. 282: (April 1876): 285–323.
Two years after publication, comments on Green’s ‘extraordinary popularity’ and on the praise of other periodicals. The style is readable and attractive, while ‘a lively imagination, not always under the most rigid control, imparts its own colours to the dry details of history, where a more scrupulous or conscientious writer would have wearied himself, and fatigued his readers, unwilling to venture beyond the arid region of facts.’ Sternly insists on historians sticking to the facts, especially in histories for the young. Reviewed: Green, J.R. A Short History of the English People. 1874. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Craik, Henry.“History of English Thought in the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 143, no. 286: (April 1877): 404–23.
The anonymous reviewer (Craik) finds the book dull despite the author’s research and style; his method is problematic, because he chooses the wrong writers to study. Reviewed: Stephen, Leslie. History of English Thought in the Eighteenth Century. 1876. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Douglas, Robert K.“History of the Mongols from the Ninth to the Nineteenth Century.” Quarterly, 144, no. 288: (October 1877): 351–79.
Writing history of this kind is admitted to be difficult. Howorth has done well despite his ignorance of Asian languages. Reviewed: Howorth, Henry H. History of the Mongols from the Ninth to the Nineteenth Century. 1876.
Acton, J. D.“Democracy in Europe; a History.” Quarterly, 145, no. 289: (1878): 112–42.
The author, Sir Erskine May, is a long-serving MP. The reviewer (J. D. Acton) says it’s based on ‘sound sense and tried experience rather than dogmatic precept’. The subject is democracies, rather than democracy as a principle. Reviewed: May, Thomas Erskine. Democracy in Europe; a History. 1877. Attribution Wellesley Index.
Hayward, Abraham.“A History of England in the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 145, no. 290: (April 1878): 498–534.
Praise for Lecky’s plan and its execution. Nevertheless, some aspects are omitted; and he overestimates the influence of Methodism. Reviewed: Lecky, William Edward Hartpole. A History of England in the Eighteenth Century. vol I and II. 1878. {attribution Wellesley Index}. See also other volumes reviewed in1882, 1887 and 1891.
Doyle, John A.“History of the Life and Times of James Madison.” Quarterly, 145, no. 290: (April 1878): 475–97.
Two books published in 1859 and 1867 are discussed, from the perspective of constitutional history. Admires Rives’s approach. Reviewed: Rives, William C. History of the Life and Times of James Madison. vol. I. 1859. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Cave-Browne, John.“The History and Antiquities of the Archiepiscopal Palace of Lambeth; with an Appendix.” Quarterly, 146, no. 291: (July 1878): 100–140.
This 1806 work is reviewed along with others on Lambeth, and Stray Studies from History of England, by J. R. Green (1867); Reviewed: Ducarel, A.C. The History and Antiquities of the Archiepiscopal Palace of Lambeth; with an Appendix. 1806l {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Hole, Charles.“The Constitutional History of England in Its Origin and Development.” Quarterly, 147, no. 294: (April 1879): 511–32.
Framed as an essay on Early English History, including William Bright’s 1878 book on Church history, and two others. Stubbs’s scholarship is praised for thoroughness. The anonymous reviewer (Hole) refers to his comment on Green’s History of the English People, some years ago. Reviewed: Stubbs, William. The Constitutional History of England in its Origin and Development. 1874-1878. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Davies, James.“Collections towards the History and Antiquities of Herefordshire.” Quarterly, 148, no. 295: (July 1879): 143–86.
Essay discusses 11 works on the county. Reviewed: Duncumb, John. Collections towards the History and Antiquities of Herefordshire. vol. I & II. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Dickins, F. V.“Japan: Its History, Traditions, and Religions, with the Narrative of a Visit to Japan in 1879.” Quarterly, 150, no. 300: (October 1880): 305–36.
Context is recent political events in Japan. Observes that ‘the annals of Japan are not inviting reading’ but Reed has done his best. Reviewed: Reed, Sir E.J. Japan: its History, Traditions, and Religions, with the Narrative of a Visit to Japan in 1879. 1880. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Courthope, W. J.“A History of England from the Conclusion of the Great War in 1815.” Quarterly, 152, no. 303: (July 1881): 239–71.
Recognizes that absolute impartiality is impossible for the historian -- rather, accuracy, dignity and sense of proportion. However Walpole’s work in the Radical interest fails these basic requirements and is poorly written. Reviewed: Walpole, Spencer. A History of England from the Conclusion of the great War in 1815. 1878-1880. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Hayward, Abraham.“Histoire Du Luxe, Prive et Public, Depuis l’Antiquite Jusqu’a Nos Jours (History of Luxury, Private and Public, from Antiquity down to Our Time).” Quarterly, 152, no. 304: (October 1881): 486–526.
Describes the book as ‘a history of manners and morals, modes of life and customs, arts, industry, commerce and civilization, in all ages and all quarters of the world.’ Reviewed: Baudrillart, H. Histoire du Luxe, Prive et Public, depuis l’Antiquite jusqu’a nos Jours (History of Luxury, Private and Public, from Antiquity down to our Time). 1880. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Hayward, Abraham.“A History of England in the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 153, no. 306: (April 1882): 489–529.
Praise for these volumes covering the American revolution. Reviewed: Lecky, William Edward Hartpole. A History of England in the Eighteenth Century. vol. III & IV. 1882.{attribution Wellesley Index}. See also other volumes reviewed in 1878, 1887 and 1891.
Tipping, Henry Avray.“A History of Agriculture and Prices.” Quarterly, 157, no. 313: (January 1884): 92–124.
Observes that the author boasts of his labours and complains they have been ignored; but he depends too much on early-modern account books and not enough on the general literature of the time. Reviewed: Thorold Rogers, James E. A History of Agriculture and Prices. vol. III & IV. 1882. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Butcher, C. H.“A Short History of the Copts and of Their Church; Translated from the Arabic of Taqui-Ed-Din El-Maqrizi.” Quarterly, 157, no. 313: (January 1884): 125–43.
An essay on the subject, with little reference to any of the works under review. Reviewed: Malan, Rev. S.C. A short History of the Copts and of their Church; translated from the Arabic of Taqui-ed-Din El-Maqrizi. 1873. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Saintsbury, George.“A History of London.” Quarterly, 158, no. 315: (July 1884): 1–39.
The context is recent changes to London infrastructure and government. Notes that the first edition was published only a year earlier. Loftie is a capable historian, despite a few errors of detail and dependence on untrustworthy sources. Comments on the ‘amorphous amplitude’ of much current historical writing. Reviewed: Loftie, W. J. A History of London. 2nd ed. 1884.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Morris, Mowbray.“Thomas Carlyle: A History of the First Forty Years of His Life, 1795-1835.” Quarterly, 159, no. 317: (January 1885): 76–112.
This essay is written in the context of the scandal raised by Froude’s revelations about the Carlyle marriage. The reviewer (Mowbray Morris) regrets Froude’s candour. Reviewed: Froude, James Anthony. Thomas Carlyle: a History of the First Forty Years of his Life, 1795-1835. 1882. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Smith, Philip.“Origins of English History.” Quarterly, 159, no. 318: (April 1885): 424–50.
This essay also reviews J. R. Green’s The Making of England (1881) and The Conquest of England (1883), along with a new edition of The Student’s Hume by J. S. Brewer (1880). Notes that Brewer reviewed Green, and that both have recently died. Discusses their methodology in the context of recent work by Freeman and others -- the focus on Englishness (rather than a Celtic character) in British identity. Reviewed: Elton, Charles. . Origins of English History. 1882.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palgrave, R. H. I.“History of Taxation and Taxes in England, from the Earliest Times to the Present Day.” Quarterly, 161, no. 322: (October 1885): 382–410.
Notes that Dowell works in the office of Inland Revenue. Reviewed: Dowell, Stephen. History of Taxation and Taxes in England, from the earliest Times to the present Day. 1884.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palmer, Arthur.“History of the British Turf, from the Earliest Times to the Present Day.” Quarterly, 161, no. 322: (October 1885): 441–69.
The reviewer is unable to speak highly of Rice’s work, which is not sufficiently authoritative or detailed. Other works reviewed are about contemporary racing. Reviewed: Rice, James. History of the British Turf, from the Earliest Times to the Present Day. 1879. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Yule, Henry.“History of Burma, &c.” Quarterly, 162, no. 323: (January 1886): 210–38.
One of the works included in this list of 9 is by the anonymous reviewer (Narrative of the Mission sent to the Court of Ava in 1855, by Captain H. Yule. 1858) Phayre is eulogized as ‘one of the few survivors of the best old school of Indian “Soldier Politicals”.’ The subject of Burma is unattractive but the book is excellent. Yule’s own book is not mentioned. Reviewed: Phayre, Sir Arthur P. History of Burma, &c. 1883. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Russell, George William Erskine.“History of England in the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 165, no. 330: (1887): 500–534.
Describes Lecky as ‘an Irishman who has been already recognized as one of the most accomplished writers of the Victorian era’. His coverage is judicious. Reviewed with other works relating to Britain and Ireland (includes a comment on Gladstone’s review of one of the other works). Reviewed: Lecky, W.E.H. History of England in the Eighteenth Century. vol. II 1878, vol.IV 1882, vol. VI 1887. Attribution Wellesley Index. See also other volumes reviewed in 1878, 1882 and 1891.
Knightly, Louise Mary.“History of Antiquities of the County of Suffolk, with Genealogical and Architectural Notices of Its Several Towns and Villages.” Quarterly, 164, no. 328: (April 1887): 382–414.
Suckling’s ‘painstaking’ work -- published almost 20 years earlier -- is among those discussed in the context of county history. Reviewed: Suckling, Rev. Alfred. History of Antiquities of the County of Suffolk, with genealogical and architectural notices of its several towns and villages.1848. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Whittle, James Lowry.“History of England from the Conclusion of the Great War in 1815.” Quarterly, 164, no. 328: (April 1887): 507–40.
Continues the 1881 critique of the earlier volumes -- ‘an unsatisfactory book, notwithstanding the diligence, and, we gladly add, the ability of the author.’ But this is social policy, not history. Notes that Walpole ‘claims comparison with Macaulay’. Reviewed: Walpole, Spencer. History of England from the Conclusion of the Great War in 1815. vol. III-V. 1880-1886. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Mallock, W. H.“Chapters in European History, with an Introductory Dialogue on the Philosophy of History.” Quarterly, 165, no. 329: (July 1887): 127–58.
Discusses Lilly’s method and his protest against the contemporary popular view of the role of evolution and determinism in historical change. Reviewed: Lilly, William Samuel. Chapters in European History, with an Introductory Dialogue on the Philosophy of History. 1886. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Whittle, James Lowry.“He Architectural History of the University of Cambridge, and of the Colleges of Cambridge and Eton.” Quarterly, 165, no. 330: (October 1887): 400–437.
Under review is an older work, recently edited and expanded by the nephew of the original author, John Willis Clark. Comments favourably on the work of the Cambridge University Press and the beauty of the illustrations. Reviewed: Willis, Robert. The Architectural History of the University of Cambridge, and of the Colleges of Cambridge and Eton. ed. John Willis Clark. 1886. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Littledale, R. F.“The History of Catholic Emancipation.” Quarterly, 166, no. 331: (January 1888): 31–62.
One of seven works on the politics of Catholicism. Reviewed: Amherst, W.J. The History of Catholic Emancipation. 1886. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gregory, Robert.“The Constitutional History of England.” Quarterly, 167, no. 333: (July 1888): 136–61.
Discusses the minutiae of church history (especially Convocation), referring to Stubbs’s 10-year-old work. Reviewed: Stubbs, W. The Constitutional History of England. 1875-1878. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Murray, John.“The Correspondence of John Lothrop Motley, D.C.L., Formerly United States Minister in England; Author of ‘Rise of the Dutch Republic,’ ‘History of the United Netherlands,’ &c.” Quarterly, 168, no. 336: (April 1889): 297–331.
The historian’s correspondence is of interest in Britain because he spent so much time in London. Reviewed: The Correspondence of John Lothrop Motley, D.C.L., formerly United States Minister in England; Author of ‘Rise of the Dutch Republic,’ ‘History of the United Netherlands,’ &c. ed. George William Curtis. 1889. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Courtenay, Boyle.“The History of Duels.” Quarterly, 169, no. 337: (July 1889): 189–221.
Cockburn’s 1720 book has been privately reprinted. Reviewed: Cockburn, John. The History of Duels. 1888. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Cornish, F. W.“History of the Great Civil War, 1642-1649.” Quarterly, 169, no. 338: (October 1889): 492–527.
Comments on the new style of doing history, ‘the modern school of “research” and “tendency”,’ embraced by ‘the scientific school’. On the other hand "we rush to the publisher for new volumes of [Macaulay’s and Froude’s] works, despite their crudities and exaggerations. As for Gardiner, his knowledge is wide and he knows his period well. Reviewed: S. R. Gardiner, History of the Great Civil War, 1642-1649. Vols 1 & 2. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Dibdin, Lewis T.“History and Antiquities of the Parish of St. Saviour’s, Southwark.” Quarterly, 170, no. 340: (April 1890): 394–414.
The occasion for returning to Concanon’s 1795 work is the recent plan to restore the church in question. Reviewed: Concanon, M. & A. Morgan. History and Antiquities of the Parish of St. Saviour’s, Southwark. 1795. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Elton, C. I.“The Viking Age: The Early History, Manners, and Customs of the English-Speaking Nations. Illustrated from the Antiquities Discovered in Mounds, Cairns, and Bogs, as Well as from the Ancient Sagas and Eddas.” Quarterly, 170, no. 340: (April 1890): 347–69.
A very interesting book ‘full of every variety of picturesque illustration’. Well-researched. Reviewed: Du Chaillu, Paul B. The Viking Age: The early History, Manners, and Customs of the English-speaking Nations. Illustrated from the Antiquities discovered in Mounds, Cairns, and Bogs, as well as from the ancient Sagas and Eddas. 1889. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Cornish, F. W.“A History of Eton College, 1440-1884.” Quarterly, 171, no. 341: (July 1890): 1–27.
Under review is a new edition, revised and enlarged, published in honour of the 450th anniversary of Eton.. Reviewed: Lyte, H.C. Maxwell. A History of Eton College, 1440-1884. 1889. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Browning, Oscar.“Die Bergrundung Des Deutschen Reiches Durch Wilhelm I.” Quarterly, VOLUME 171, OCTOBER, 1890: (October 1890): 329–65.
The book discusses the unification of Germany and the foundation of the German empire. Browning describes von Sybel as ‘the first historian of his country, and perhaps since the death of Ranke the first in Europe.’ The author is Heinrich von Sybel. The 5- vol book is published in Munich and Leipzig. Attribution Wellesley Index; this entry was not picked up by the standard HiPPo methodology.
Falkiner, C. Litton.“A History of England in the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 172, no. 343: (January 1891): 1–32.
Addresses the conclusion of Lecky’s ‘great work’. Extensive coverage of Ireland continues. But some defects are identified: he tells the tale ‘in inverted commas’, not in his own words. While admiring the author’s judiciousness, the reviewer wants him to take sides. Reviewed: Lecky, W.E.H. A History of England in the Eighteenth Century. vol. VII & VIII. 1890.{Attribution Wellesley Index}See also other volumes reviewed in 1878, 1882 and 1887.
Cornish, F. W.“Studies in European History, Being Academical Addresses Delivered by JOHN IGNATIUS VON DOLLINGER, D.D., Late Professor of Ecclesiastical History in the University of Munich.” Quarterly, 172, no. 343: (January 1891): 33–64.
Speaks respectfully of Dollinger’s history -writing -- more like Ranke than Mommsen or Stubbs, powerful knowledge but not much style. Reviewed: Studies in European History, being Academical Addresses delivered by John Ignatius von Dollinger, D.D., late Professor of Ecclesiastical History in the University of Munich. Trans. Margaret Warre. 1890. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Emmett, J. T.“London Past and Present, Its History, Associations, and Traditions.” Quarterly, 174, no. 348: (April 1892): 393–422.
The book allows the reviewer to sketch London himself. Reviewed: Henry B. Wheatley, London Past and Present, 1891. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Round, J. Horace.“The History of the Norman Conquest of England.” Quarterly, 175, no. 349: (July 1892): 1–37.
Freeman’s adversary begins his scathing anonymous review with a lament for the author’s death. Focus of the article is Freeman’s place in the history curriculum, and his authority and accuracy as a historian. He lacked a sense of proportion; he was narrow-minded, even bigoted, and pedantic. Round compares the movement for a newly scientific history to that of the Pre-Raphaelites (love of detail), but charges Freeman with inaccuracy. Reviewed: Freeman, E.A. The History of the Norman Conquest of England. vol. I & II. 3rd ed. 1877. vol. III & IV. 2nd ed. 1875/1876. Also reviews Freeman’s History of William Rufus, 1882. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Dixon, William Macneile.“The History of the University of Dublin, from Its Foundation to the End of the Eighteenth Century.” Quarterly, 175, no. 349: (July 1892): 162–87.
Reviewer is an Irish academic. No comment on Stubbs’s authorship or views. Reviewed: Stubbs, John William. The History of the University of Dublin, from its Foundation to the end of the Eighteenth Century. 1889. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Gardner, Percy.“The History of Sicily from the Earliest Times.” Quarterly, 175, no. 350: (October 1892): 319–47.
Discusses posthumous publication of Freeman’s work; no great liking for his historical theories, but ‘regret at the loss of so efficient and accomplished a workman in history, so interesting and consistent a political opponent so warm-hearted and generous a friend.’ Focus is on Freeman’s ethnology of racial purity. Reviewed: Freeman, Edward A. The History of Sicily from the Earliest Times. vol. I -III. 1891/1892. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Barry, William.“History of the Jews from the Earliest Times to the Present Day.” Quarterly, 176, no. 351: (January 1893): 106–39.
Praises the work ‘as honourable to the nation (i.e. Judaeism) of which he was both historian and apologist as to himself.’ But of course his ‘point of sight cannot be ours’. Reviewed: Graetz, Prof. H. History of the Jews from the Earliest Times to the Present Day. Edited and in part trans. by Bella Lowy. 5 vol. 1891-1892. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Parry, F. S.“History and Antiquities of the Exchequer.” Quarterly, 178, no. 355: (January 1894): 215–34.
Jokingly refers to what Macaulay’s schoolboy does and does not know about the arcane rules of Parliamentary procedure, and in particular the stewardship of the Chiltern Hundreds. Reviewed: Madox, Thomas. History and Antiquities of the Exchequer. 1711. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Barry, William.“The History of the Jews.” Quarterly, 183, no. 365: (January 1896): 29–57.
Discusses vol 5 of the book reviewed three years earlier, along with others on related subjects. Reviewed: Graetz, H. The History of the Jews. vol. V. 1892. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Parry, Ernest.“A History of Gardening in England.” Quarterly, 184, no. 367: (July 1896): 54–75.
Described as ‘a clear and very readable sketch’ of a vast subject. Author abstains from discursiveness. Reviewed: Amherst, Alicia. A History of Gardening in England. 1895. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Wilson, Herbert W.“History of the United States from the Compromise of 1850.” Quarterly, 185, no. 369: (January 1897): 214–40.
Discussion of several works on the American civil war. A new generation of historians can be impartial for the first time, writing ‘without even an unconscious bias’. Reviewed: Rhodes, J.F. History of the United States from the Compromise of 1850. vol. III. 1895. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Falkiner, C. Litton.“History of the Irish Rebellion in 1798.” Quarterly, 187, no. 373: (January 1898): 31–60.
The fact that the subject lives in popular memory is the occasion for this and other centenary works under review. Reviewed: Maxwell, W.H. History of the Irish Rebellion in 1798. 1894. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Cornish, F. W.“Gardiner’s History of the Commonwealth and Protectorate.” Quarterly, 187, no. 374: (April 1898): 446–70.
Reviewer (Cornish) observes that ‘Histories, as they are written nowadays, make a greater demand upon the reader’s leisure than the ancient quartos or even the octavos of Macaulay and Froude. The modern historian gives the public too much of his material. ... The university schools of history have created such a rage for accuracy that historians are afraid to hazard any statement without giving full proofs.’ Cornish wants someone of Gardiner’s calibre to instruct and enlighten, to pronounce judgments. ‘If Clio listens to Sir John Seeley (who was better than his creed) and condescends to be dull, she will become a Danaid, not a Muse . . . and if the public does not read, the publisher will not print, and so Clio is starved out.’ Reviewed: Samuel Rawson Gardiner, History of the Commonwealth and Protectorate. vol. I and II. 1894/1897.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Palgrave, R. H. I.“A History of Banks, Bankers, and Banking in Northumberland, Durham, and North Yorkshire.” Quarterly, 190, no. 379: (1899): 128–52.
Discusses various works on the subject of banks and banking, refreshing readers’ knowledge of recent events. Reviewed: Phillips, Maberly. A History of Banks, Bankers, and Banking in Northumberland, Durham, and North Yorkshire. 1894. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
George, Hereford B.“A History of the Art of War: The Middle Ages, from the Fourth to the Fourteenth Century.” Quarterly, 189, no. 378: (April 1899): 337–58.
Compares Oman’s work favourably with various European works also discussed, although his starting-point is open to criticism. Reviewed: Oman, Charles. A History of the Art of War: the Middle Ages, from the Fourth to the Fourteenth Century. 1898. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Drage, Geoffrey.“History of the English Poor Law.” Quarterly, 191, no. 381: (January 1900): 154–75.
Described as ‘a remarkable book, written in a popular style’ which amounts to a defence of the reforms of 1834; the reviewer (Drage) notes that the author has himself worked with poor people. Mostly concerned with contemporary social policy. Reviewed: T. Mackay, History of the English Poor Law. Vol 3. 1899 -- in conjunction with various contemporary royal commission reports.{attribution Wellesley Index}.
Hall, Hubert.“Dr. Theal on South African History.” Quarterly, 192, no. 383: (July 1900): 1–24.
Discusses 6 works in all, 3 of them by ‘the veteran historiographer of our distressful colony [who] has been at work among the London archives’. Regrets that the London-based research was available only for the most recent edition of Theal’s history. The older work (based on Cape Town records) gives some justification for sympathy with the Boers, whereas the new archival research in the PRO disproves that view. But it is poorly edited. Reviewed: Theal, G. McCall. Records of the Cape Colony, Copied for the Manuscript Documents in the Public Record Office, London. Vol. I-V. 1795-1806. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
Wallace, William.“Early Scottish History.” Quarterly, 192, no. 384: (October 1900): 455–76.
Discusses 10 works in all, including one by Andrew Lang (‘the most vivacious and most critical history of his native country that has yet been written’). Hume Brown’s book exhibits ‘calm lucidity’ and Lang’s ‘gay wisdom’. But more work remains to be done on the subject. Reviewed: Hume Brown, P. History of Scotland. vol. I To the Accession of Mary Stewart. 1899. {attribution Wellesley Index}.
“THE FUTURE OF GREEK HISTORY.” Quarterly, 195, no. 389: (1902): 79–97.
The subject is fascinating but the evidence is scant. Grundy’s work is praised for scholarly excellence. Discusses the uses of textual criticism for historical studies. Reviewed: Grundy, G.B. The Great Persian War and its Preliminaries. 1901 and two other works.
Gooch, G. P.“THE HISTORY OF MANKIND.” Quarterly, 198, no. 395: (1903): 28–55.
The first volume of the Cambridge Modern History is reviewed with 7 others (including one of Ranke’s) dealing with world history. Discusses Lord Acton’s role in the project and engages in detailed criticism of the volume. Reviewed: The Cambridge Modern History. vol. I. ed. A.W. Ward, G.W. Prothero, and Stanley Leathes. 1903.
Lloyd, E. M.“THE HISTORY OF THE BRITISH ARMY.” Quarterly, 199, no. 397: (1904): 32–56.
Fortescue’s book is reviewed with others on military history. Praise for the scale of his work, but when it comes to the American revolution he gets bogged down in the detail. Reviewed: Fortescue, J.W. A History of the British Army. vol. I-III. 1899-1902.