Tait's Edinburgh
Published 1832-1861. Monthly, 1s. A rival to Blackwood’s Magazine. Initially published by politically radical Edinburgh bookseller William Tait and later moved to London. Began as a political periodical but later became more literary. (See DNCJ, where all quotations appear, for further information and references to additional sources.)
“Memoir of Sebastian Cabot.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 1, no. 1: (April 1832): 131–32.
Examines this biography of the son of John Cabot and states that the author does an excellent job with his triumphant and sarcastic tone to examine Cabot’s life. Reviewed: Biddle, Richard. Memoir of Sebastian Cabot, with a Review of the History of Maritime Discovery; illustrated by Documents from the Rolls, now first published. London: Hurst, Chance, & co, 1831.
Johnstone, Christian Isobel, Thomas Doubleday, and J. J. Darling.“Biographical History of the Wesley Family.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 11: (February 1833): 674.
Brief notice states that this work is well done, offering interesting information on the founders of the American Methodist church. Reviewed: Dove, John. Biographical History of the Wesley Family.
“History of Europe during the French Revolution.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 16: (July 1833): 496–510.
States that this work is eloquent, interesting, very descriptive and overall well done. It does point out some specific things that Alison left out and some opinions about the politics of the revolution that the reviewer did not agree with. The review contains a description of the work with excerpts as well. Reviewed: Alison, Archibald. Embracing the Period from the Assembly of the Notables, in 1789, to the Establishment of the Directory, in 1795. Edinburgh: William Blackwood & London: T. Cadell and Stand, 1833.
“English History for the People of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 18: (September 1833): 809.
The design of the work is praiseworthy and the overall idea of the work good. Reviewed: English History for the People of England. London: Cambridge, Heward.
“PEDESTRIAN TOURS IN SWITZERLAND.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 18: (September 1833): 805–6.
States that although this work offers readers a pleasant voyage through the Swiss hills with journal entries it is not very informative and skips the history of Switzerland. Reviewed: Agassiz, L. PEDESTRIAN TOURS IN SWITZERLAND, with a Sketch of its History and of the Manners and Customs. London: Smith, Elder & co.
Dumas, Alexandre.“Philosophy of French History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 21: (December 1833): 341–42.
Briefly offers extracts and examines various events in French history, mostly of the early nineteenth century (the book is judged not very useful).
“The History of Wales.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 22: (January 1834): 506.
Claims this is a useful little work (very brief review). Reviewed: ‘By a Welsh Lady’ The History of Wales: Arranged as a Cathecism. Shrewsbury: Eddowses.
“Lardner’s Cyclopoedia-History of Rome, Vol. I.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 1, no. 2: (March 1834): 135.
States this work is the best work of Larder thus far in offering readers valuable and original information and recommends it to readers claiming overall it is excellent. Reviewed: Lardner, Thomas. History of Rome, Vol. I. Longman, Rees, and Orme, 1833.
“History of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (April 1834): 210.
States that this valuable work is approached fairly and that this work is an overall important addition to history. Reviewed: Reid, Rev James Seaton. History of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. Edinburgh: Waugh and Innes.
Johnstone, Christian Isobel.“Sir James Mackintosh’s History of the Revolution of 1688.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (May 1834): 247–58.
This review mainly focuses on the book’s preface regarding the life of Sir James and does not get to reviewing the actual historical portion of the work. The review in discusses the life (private and public) of Mackintosh and states that the work overall is well-written, fair and impartial, yet expensive for a book that spends so much time on the biography of its author. Reviewed: History of the Revolution of 1688. 1834. (complete upon Mackintosh’s death by William Wallace).
Burton, John Hill.“History of Scotland.-Vol. V.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 1, no. 8: (September 1834): 521–27.
Reviewer examines the content of past 4 volumes and the content of the present fifth volume. States that while Tytler is a passionate and dedicated researcher and writer he may overvalue or overemphasize the importance of his original findings. Nevertheless, the next volumes are much anticipated. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland.-Vol. V. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“Tytler’s History of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (September 1834): 354.
States that the 5th volume of this work is useful as it offers original information as it examines a portion of the reign of James IV and the whole reign of James V. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland.
“Gutzlaff’s Sketch of Chinese History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 13: (January 1835): 44–52.
States that this work is a useful collection of facts but its utility is limited insofar as it does not present events in appropriate proportion, due to its chronological basis. The reviewers also offers a detailed account of the content of the work. Reviewed: Gutzlaff, Charles. Sketch of Chinese History.
“Private History of the London Newspaper Press.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 1, no. 11: (January 1835): 788–92.
Examines the evolution of the Newspaper press in London by looking at the divisions of the newspaper medium into many different newspapers and the men involved in this evolutionary process.
“Aikman’s History of Religious Liberty in England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 15: (March 1835): 206.
States the importance and usefulness of this multi-volume collection, which is broken up into manageable volumes making it cheap, concise, and very useful to all readers. Reviewed: Aikman, James. History of Religious Liberty in England.
“Baines History of the Cotton Manufacture.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 16: (April 1835): 235–52.
The reviewer states that the author is well equipped for the task of examining the history of cotton manufacturing as he is accurate, impartial, candid, and a dedicated researcher. States that the work is much needed as this industry is of the greatest importance and that this work is overall very interesting. Then goes on to examine the content of the work with many lengthy excerpts. Reviewed: Baines, Edward. History of the Cotton Manufacture.
“Cooper’s Parliamentary History of the Country of Sussex.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 17: (May 1835): 351.
‘An interesting morsel of county history’ (the content of the entire review is this sentence).
“Scenes and Legends of the North of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 17: (May 1835): 350.
States that this work is interesting, clever, entertaining, well-written, contains original and valuable information. Reviewed: Miller, Hugh. Scenes and Legends of the North of Scotland, or the Traditional History of Cromarty. Edinburgh: Adam & Charles Black).
“History and Present Condition of the Barbury States.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 18: (June 1835): 419–20.
States this work is full of valuable and interesting information and contains well-done and useful engravings. Reviewed: Russell, Rev. Michael. History and Present Condition of the Barbury States.
“A History and Description of the Late Houses of Parliament.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 19: (July 1835): 487.
Simply states that engravings are bold and clever.
“Chronological Tables of Ancient History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 20: (August 1835): 554.
States that the tables are copious and complete and the work is of immense use to ‘instructors of youth’ and for older readers as its mass of historical facts can be useful.
“Moore’s History of Ireland-Cabinet Cyclopaedia.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 17: (August 1835): 349.
States that Thomas Moore, generally considered a poet, has gone beyond his title and done an effective job of presenting this history. Offers content and excerpts from the work.
“The History of the Assassins.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 20: (August 1835): 554.
Contents are amusing and useful. Reviewed: Hammer, M. Von. The History of the Assassins. Trans. Oswald Charles Wood.
“The Philosophy of History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 2, no. 24: (December 1835): 828.
Scan is illegible. Reviewed: Schlegel, Fredrick Von. The Philosophy of History. London: Saunders & Otley.
Johnstone, Christian Isobel.“Hogarth’s History of Music.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 26: (February 1836): 80–87.
States that Hogarth is impartial and selects good information to include in this useful, delightful, and sound work. To know the book is to appreciate it. Publisher is Parker.
“Knickerbocker’s History of New York.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 27: (March 1836): 201.
The original work is praised, and this new edition is notable for useful and competent illustrations.
“Wallen’s History of the Round Church at Little Mapplestead.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 30: (June 1836): 409.
This ‘curious and pleasant’ work is a ‘good epitome of the history of the crusaders’.
“Armitag ’s History of Brazil.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 31: (July 1836): 472.
ProQuest scan is illegible.
“Admiral Napier’s History of the War in Portugal.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 33: (September 1836): 610–11.
Notes that this interesting and useful work is useful not only as a personal narrative, but also as a source of useful insight into the political Cabinet of the time.
Burton, John Hill.“Gregory’s History of the Western Highlands and Isles of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 33: (September 1836): 574–89.
States that Gregory’s closer connection to his topic has benefitted the book, and resulted in a work full of useful information that is an ‘essential service’. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“Wheeler’s History of Manchester.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 3, no. 35: (November 1836): 752.
Notes that this work is useful and contains interesting statistics and information; however the author attempts to appear dispassionate and impartial, but his political views are not very well masked.
Burton, John Hill.“History of the Church of Scotland, in Relation to Endowments; by Alexander Fyfe, Surgeon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 37: (January 1837): 17–23.
Notes that this well compiled historical work is honest and contains good, and often startling, information. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
Johnstone, Christian Isobel.“New Lights Thrown, by M. Von Raumer, on the Private and Personal History of Queen Elizabeth and Mary Queen of Scots.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 38: (February 1837): 118–25.
Notes that this work contains interesting and entertaining content, but that Raumer may not have been entirely impartial as he clearly sides with Elizabeth. Reviewed: Raumer, M. Von. Contributions to Modern History.
Doubleday, Thomas.“The History of England Made Visible.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 38: (February 1837): 128.
Notes that this work is entertaining and instructive, with its many illustrations. Reviewed: Williams, Charles. The History of England Made Visible. London: Westley & Davis.
“In History and Biography,.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 41: (May 1837): 332.
States that this work is one of the most interesting works on the subject. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. Life of Henry VIII.
“The Highlanders of Scotland-Their Origin, History, and Antiquities.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 44: (August 1837): 531–32.
Judges that this work is very unflattering to its subjects. Reviewed: Skene, William F. The Highlanders of Scotland-their Origin, History, and Antiquities.
“Dr Lang’s History of New South Wales.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 45: (September 1837): 600.
States that this second edition is enlarged and improved.
Burton, John Hill.“Tytler’s History of Scotland.-Vol. VI.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 4, no. 48: (December 1837): 769–80.
States that that the fulness and accuracy of this work makes it one of the best on the subject, and that Tytler’s use of original documents (which allows him to shed new light on well-known issues) allows him to surpass the works of many past historians’ works on the subject. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland. Vol. VI. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Commons of Great Britain and Ireland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 5, no. 50: (February 1838): 131.
States that this ‘amusing and curious’ work is both interesting and valuable.
“The Family Library, No. LXIV. A History of the Bastile and of the Principal Captives.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 5, no. 51: (March 1838): 196.
Review judges this to be a very curious and interesting work.
“An Epitome of the History and Geography of Greece.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 5, no. 58: (October 1838): 673.
The reviewer states that, although he did not read much of the work, it seemed pleasing to the eye and would be beneficial for any classics teacher who might chose to look at it more closely.
Reviewed: Carr, Thomas Swinburne. An Epitome of the History and Geography of Greece.
“Wilson’s History of Christ’s Hospital.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 5, no. 58: (October 1838): 673.
Notes that this is an interesting new edition.
“Ancient Scottish Melodies; from a M.S. of the Reign of James VI.; with an Introductory Inquiry, Illustrative of the History of the Music of Scotland, by William Dauney, Esq.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 61: (January 1839): 53–54.
Notes that the most interesting and valuable part of this work is the collection of music by John Skene which is translated with great care.
Tait, William.“Price’s History of Protestant Nonconformity.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 61: (January 1839): 56–57.
States that this second volume may have been published too long after the first to get much notice, but that it is nevertheless complete on a subject of great importance. Contains a lengthy except which is judged to be the best excerpt to appeal to popular taste.
“The History, Rise, and Progress of the New Colony of South Australia.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 63: (March 1839): 195.
Notes that although the author takes a more sober tone in this second edition he is somewhat biased in focusing more on certain areas of Australia than on others. Reviewed: Stephens, John. The History, Rise, and Progress of the New Colony of South Australia. 2nd ed.
Darling, James Johnston.“Tooke’s History of Prices, and of the State of the Circulation from 1793 to 1837.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 63: (March 1839): 153–56.
States that this edition is enlarged and improved and recommends the work for those who have broader questions about matters pertaining to currency. Reviewed: Tooke, Thomas. A History of Prices, and of the State of the Circulation from 1793 to 1837; preceded by a Brief Sketch of the state of the Corn Trade in the last two centuries. London: Longman & co.
“Ellis’s History of Madagascar.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 64: (April 1839): 221–37.
States that this is the finest work done on the history of the Island and that engravings are accurate. Includes a summary of the content and offers various excerpts. Reviewed: Ellis. History of Madagascar. Fisher, Son & co.
“Pictorial History of Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 64: (April 1839): 278.
States that Part 1 of this compilation of works about Napoleon is well put together, detailed and contains good engravings. Reviewed: Pictorial History of Napoleon. ed. R.H Horne.
“The Pictorial History of Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 65: (May 1839): 345.
Reiterates that this work is full of character and has many engravings. Reviewed: The Pictorial History of Napoleon. Part II. ed. R.H. Horne.
“Chronicle of the Law Officers of Ireland, with an Outline of the Legal History of Ireland, Chronological Tables, &c., &c.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 67: (July 1839): 480.
States that this work will be of value only to those in the profession and specifically to young lawyers. Reviewed: Senyth, Constantine B. Chronicle of the Law Officers of Ireland, with an Outline of the Legal History of Ireland, Chronological Tables.
“History of the Dukes of Normandy, from the Time of Rollo to the Expulsion of King John.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 67: (July 1839): 474.
States that this work is vague and limited; does not explore Norman literature or the state of the arts as much as would be desired. Reviewed: Duncan, Johnathan. History of the Dukes of Normandy, from the Time of Rollo to the Expulsion of King John.
“British History, from the Invasion of the Romans to the Accession of Queen Victoria.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 69: (September 1839): 617.
States that although this work could be improved, there is no other book that can take its place in terms of information. Reviewed: Wade, John. British History, from the Invasion of the Romans to the Accession of Queen Victoria.
“The Rhine-Legends, Traditions, and History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 70: (October 1839): 691.
States that this work is wonderful; a complete collection of the lore and history behind every village and town of the Rhine, and that is can best be described as a prose epic. Reviewed: Snowe, Joseph. The Rhine-Legends, Traditions, and History.
“History of the Campaign in France in 1814.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 6, no. 71: (November 1839): 761–62.
Notes that this work glorifies the Russian army throughout and would thus not be likely to offend any Russian Emperor, past, present, or future. Reviewed: Mikhailofsky-Danielefsky, A. History of the Campaign in France in 1814.
“Thornton’s Chapters on the Modern History of India.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 73: (January 1840): 62–63.
States that the author may have used too much of a European framework to analyze India.
“History of Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 76: (April 1840): 268.
With respect to part 13, notes that this work is oversupplied with illustrations on the same subject which create repetition. Reviewed: Tyre. History of Napoleon. Part 13.
“Bodin’s Summary of the History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 77: (May 1840): 339.
States that this work is useful to English readers as it offers a new perspective on English history from a non-native perspective. Reviewed: [Felix] Bodin’s Summary of the History of England. trans. Jonathan Duncan.
Burton, John Hill.“Esther Copley’s History of Slavery and Its Abolition.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 78: (June 1840): 399.
States that this new edition does contain new appendices but does not discuss the new parliamentary developments with regard to slavery. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“The History of Brechin.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 81: (September 1840): 604.
Claims that Black is just the right man to write this history as he is a town hall official. Reviewed: Black, David. The History of Brechin.
Burton, John Hill.“Tytler’s History of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 82: (October 1840): [613]-628.
States that this work is focused one of the most interesting periods of Scottish history; it contains new and authentic facts and is overall well-researched and written. Reviewed: Tytler, Patrick Fraser. History of Scotland. Vol. 6. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“The History of the Jews, from the Taking of Jerusalem by Titus to the Present Time.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 7, no. 84: (December 1840): 806.
States that this work is as much an attempt to convert Jews as it is a history of the Jews.
“DR. OLIVER’S HISTORY of FREEMASONRY, from 1829 to the PRESENT TIME.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 89: (May 1841): 334.
States that this compilation of new papers is of no great interest.
“THE HISTORY of INITIATION.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 89: (May 1841): 334.
States that this work is amusing especially the part about gothic history. Reviewed: Oliver, Rev. George. The History of Initiation; comprising an Account of the Rite and Ceremonies, Doctrines, and Disciplines, of all the Secret and Mysterious Institutions of the Ancient World.
“General Views of the History and Literature of Italy.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 91: (July 1841): 469–70.
Notes that this work will be useful to foreigners to Italy, offering an understanding of its thought and history. Also states that the chapters on recent history are lacking as they are few and brief. Reviewed: Mariotti, L. General Views of the History and Literature of Italy. Saunders & Otley.
“TYTLER’S HISTORY OF SCOTLAND, Volume III.; Containing the Reigns of Robert II. and III.; the Regency of Albany, and the Reign of James I.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 93: (September 1841): 610.
States this volume is a continuation of Tytler’s long career of fine historical research, including the investigation of controversial points.
“Sketches of Scottish Church History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 94: (October 1841): 673–74.
ProQuest scan is illegible. Reviewed: McCrie, Thomas. Sketches of Scottish Church History.
“Sricenor’s History of the Iron Trade.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 94: (October 1841): 674.
ProQuest scan is illegible.
“The Book of the Bastiles; of, The History of the Working of the New Poor Law.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 94: (October 1841): 674.
ProQuest scan is illegible. Reviewed: Baxter, Wythen. The Book of the Bastiles; of, The History of the Working of the New Poor law.
“Duncan’s History of Guernsey.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 95: (November 1841): 734–35.
Notes that this work is very complete, agreeable, and instructive. Also states that this work is credible to Duncan’s judgement, intelligence and industry. Publisher is Longman & co.
Doubleday, Thomas.“TYTLER’S HISTORY of SCOTLAND, Vol. V.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 8, no. 96: (December 1841): 809.
States that this work is well-researched, balances conflicting evidence well, and is of overall high authority. In fact, it will restore the value of Scottish history.
“A History of the Life of Richard Coeur-de-Lion.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 97: (January 1842): 57.
States that the work is incomplete as it needs a third volume and thus the reviewer merely points out what was in the introduction, offering no further critique. Reviewed: James, G.P.R. A History of the Life of Richard Coeur-de-Lion. Saunders and Otley.
“The History of the Templars, and the Temple Church, and Temple, London.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 97: (January 1842): 56–57.
ProQuest scan is illegible. Reviewed: Addison, Charles. The History of the Templars, and the Temple Church, and Temple, London. Longman & co.
“The History of the Republic of Texas.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 99: (March 1842): 199.
States that this work is biased and is not recommended to British readers, unless used as a counter argument to the previous work on the topic by ‘Mr. Kennedy’ Reviewed: Doran, N. The History of the Republic of Texas. Smith and Elder.
“The Music of the Church.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 99: (March 1842): 196–98.
Notes that this work is written for a popular audience, comprehensive and full of excellent matter. Recommends this work to all musical readers. Reviewed: Hirst, Thomas. The Music of the Church; containing a General History of Music. Whittaker & co.
Burton, John Hill.“Tytler’s History of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 101: (May 1842): 314–28.
States that 8th volume is elaborate, comprehensive, accurate, authentic, detailed and uses excellent original sources. Also notes that Tytler does an excellent job of offering a truthful, beautiful, and expressive account of historical characters to ensure that they are viewed as real persons. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“History of Christian Missions.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 102: (June 1842): 406.
States that this work is interesting and compiled with pains and ability. Reviewed: Huie, James. History of Christian Missions, from the Reformation to the Present Time. Oliver & Boyd.
“On the Use and Study of History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 102: (June 1842): 406.
Claims that this set of lectures given at The Theatre of Mechanics Institution in Dublin displays power and freedom of thought and is recommended to young men everywhere. However readers should remember that the author is an Irishman. Specifically commends the second and third lecture in the series. Reviewed: Somers, W. On the Use and Study of History. London: Longman.
Aytoun, James.“Thornton’s History of British India.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 106: (August 1842): 692.
The book is judged to be valuable with useful information. Vol. III. Part V of Thornton’s work.
“Madden’s History of the United Irishmen.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 105: (September 1842): 578–97.
Although it is noted that this work can be rambling and episodic, it is overall well-researched and authentic, containing original sources.
“The History of Poland and Russia.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 98: (December 1842): 134.
States that this work is more descriptive than historical, which is an advantage, and that it is instructive and entertaining. Reviewed: Corner, Julia. The History of Poland and Russia from the Earliest Periods to the Present Time, adapted to Youth, Schools, and Families. Dean and Munday.
“Von Rolleck’s General History of the World.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 9, no. 108: (December 1842): 816–17.
This comprehensive work benefits from the author’s liberal views and philosophical spirit and is regarded as an invaluable book for students of general and elementary history; it can take the place of many other works on various historical topics. Reviewed: Von Rollack, Charles. General History of the World; from the earliest Times to 1831. Longman & co.
“A Popular History of British India, Commercial Intercourse with China, and the Insular Possessions of England in the Eastern Seas.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 110: (February 1843): 130–33.
States that this simple narrative of facts about the empire in India offers none of the author’s own opinions or thoughts but is useful in answering general questions; the work is also beneficial in offering one of the first authentic accounts of the beginning of trade with the China. Reviewed: Taylor, W. Cooke. A Popular History of British India, Commercial Intercourse with China, and the Insular Possessions of England in the Eastern Seas. Madden & co.
“Elements of Universal History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 111: (March 1843): 201.
The most comprehensive and valuable compendium of general history, which is useful both as a reading book and as a reference work. Reviewed: White, H. Elements of Universal History. Oliver & Boyd.
Johnstone, Christian Isobel.“The History of Woman in England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 111: (March 1843): 193–96.
States that this book must have been quite a labour to research, as it examines the common women of the past. Review notes that most previous works have focused on the history of Royal women, and approves the attention to women of the workshop and the farm house. Offers many excerpts with little critique. Reviewed: Lawrance, Hannah. The History of Woman in England. vol I.
“History of Our Own Times.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 114: (June 1843): 406.
This first volume is all about the French Revolution but the work as a whole promises to be voluminous. Reviewed: History of our own Times. vol. I. Henry Colburn.
“History of the Life of Coeur-de-Lion.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 115: (July 1843): 475.
Full of interesting matter and well-researched. Reviewed: James, G.P.R. History of the Life of Coeur-de-Lion. Saunders & Otley.
“History of the Sandwich Islands.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 116: (August 1843): 537–40.
This work is full of useful facts and comes at a opportune time, as these Islands’ interaction with the Britain is increasing. Mainly discusses the content of the work. Reviewed: Jackson, James. History of the Sandwich Islands. London: Moxon.
“The Original History of Ancient America.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 117: (September 1843): 611.
The work is somewhat racy and many readers will be sceptical of the thesis and theories contained in its pages. Reviewed: Jones, George. The Original History of Ancient America, founded upon the Ruins of Antiquity: The identity of the Aborigines with the People of Tyrus and Israel, and the introduction of Christianity by the Apostle Thomas. Longman & co.
“Mesmerism; Its History, Phenomena, and Practice.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 118: (October 1843): 679.
States that the author is neither a supporter or believer of mesmerism but merely wants to add to the facts known on the subject. Reviewed: Mesmerism; its History, Phenomena, and Practice, with Reports of Cases Developed in Scotland. Edinburgh: Fraser & co. London: W.S. Orr.
John Hill Burton.“History of St. Andrews.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 10, no. 120: (December 1843): 797–802.
The book is judged to be very biased, and compiled with questionable methods. Reviewed: Lyon, C.J. Episcopal, Monastic, Academics, and Civil; comprising the principal part of the Ecclesiastical History of Scotland, from the earliest age till the present time. Edinburgh: William Tait. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
Burton, John Hill.“Tytler’s History of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 122: (February 1844): 85–94.
States this work provides a closer appeal to fact than many others, and that Tytler is more inclined to offer the naked truth of character and circumstance, leaving the reader with a very true picture of the historical period they are reading about. Reviewed: Tytler. History of Scotland. vol. IX. Edinburgh: Tait. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“Bancroft’s History of the United States of America.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 123: (March 1844): 202.
States that although this work may be criticized by some as not being history (due to the methods employed and its structure) it is put together with vitality, comprehensiveness, and breadth of view.
Reviewed: Bancroft. History of the United States of America; from the Discovery of the American Continent to the War of Independence. Edinburgh, London, and Glasgow: Fullarton.
Burton, John Hill.“Tytlers’s History of Scotland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 123: (March 1844): 156–63.
States that this ninth volume has an overall gentlemanly tone; that Tytler’s opinions are clear and decided and the work demonstrates the candour of his remarks and judgement. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“Backgammon, Its History and Practice.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 124: (April 1844): 271.
Notes that it is surprising that a whole work can be dedicated to this topic, but the work was cleverly written and well illustrated. Reviewed: Backgammon, its History and Practice, by the Author of Whist; with illustrations by Kenny Meadows.
“The Treasury of History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 124: (April 1844): 271.
Reviewer judges that the history of Great Britain is given properly, with detail and not in the usually dry and formal style. Reviewed: Maunder, Samuel. The Treasury of History; comprising a General Introductory Outline of Universal History, Ancient and Modern, and a Series of Separate Histories of every principal Nation that exists: their Rise, Progress, Present condition. Longman & co.
“The United States of America; Their History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 123: (April 1844): 202.
States this work displays great mastery on the subject; presents facts in detail in a comprehensive manner. Reviewed: Murray, Henry. The United States of America; their History from the earliest period, their Industry, Commerce, Banking Transactions, and National Works; their Institutions and Character, Political, Social, and Literary, with a Survey of their Territory, and Remarks on the prospects and plans of Emigrants. Vol. I. Oliver & Boyd.
“The United States of America: Their History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 124: (April 1844): 271.
Discusses the content of this second volume and states that the critique will come when the third volume is reviewed. Reviewed: Murray, Hugh. The United States of America: their History from the Earliest Period; their Industry, Commerce, Banking Transactions, and National Works; their Institutions and Character, Political, Social, and Literary. Vol. II. Oliver & Boyd.
“Outlines of History of Ireland, for Schools and Families.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 125: (May 1844): 336.
Entertaining, useful, creditable, and impartial. Reviewed: Publisher, in Dublin, is Curry.
“History of Ireland and the Irish People, under the Government of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 126: (June 1844): 401–2.
Judges that this work is impartial and useful to general readers in offering a continuous view of leading events in Irish history. Reviewed: Smiles, Samuel. History of Ireland and the Irish People, under the Government of England. London: Strange.
“History of England, from the Peace of Utrecht.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 127: (July 1844): 462–64.
Summarizes the content and offers excerpts. Reviewed: Lord Mahon. History of England, from the Peace of Utrecht. Vol. IV. London: John Murray.
“The History of Cleveland.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 127: (July 1844): 471–72.
States this work is useful, well printed and contains good engravings. Reviewed: Ord, J. Walker. The History of Cleveland. Part I, II, III. London: Simpkin, Marshall & co., Edinburgh: Tait.
“Maxwell’s History of the Rebellion in Ireland in 1798.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 128: (August 1844): 540.
Not actually reviewed, just listed. Part VII. London: A.H. Baily & co.
“A History of China, from the Earliest Records to the Treaty with Great Britain in 1842.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 129: (September 1844): 603–4.
Claims that although Thornton has produced an interesting volume, this topic may be too broad in scale to be complete satisfactorily in the 2 volumes he proposes.
Reviewed: Thornton, Thomas. A History of China, from the Earliest Records to the Treaty with Great Britain in 1842. London: Wm. II Allen & co.
“History of the Oregon Territory and British North American Fur Trade.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 129: (September 1844): 601–3.
States that the author makes a better narrator than a politician; he describes events well and produces an entertaining work. A lengthy excerpt is included. Reviewed: Dunn, John. History of the Oregon Territory and British North American Fur Trade; with an account of the Habits and Customs of the principle North American Tribes on the Northern Continent. London: Edward & Hughes.
“The History of the English Revolution.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 129: (September 1844): 598–601.
Work is well received, well-written and beneficial to foreigners seeking information of the subject. Reviewed: Dahlmann, F.E. The History of the English Revolution. trans. H Evans Lloyd. London: Longman & co.
“Ballads and Lays from Scottish History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 132: (December 1844): 795.
States that these national poems are animated, correct, instructive and impressive. Reviewed: Clyne, Norval. Ballads and Lays from Scottish History. Edinburgh: Shand.
“Maxwell’s History of the Irish Rebellion 1798.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 11, no. 122: (December 1844): 136.
Reviewer expresses hope that Maxwell will be less one-sided than scholars of the past. Reviewed: Maxwell. History of the Irish Rebellion 1798.
“The History of British India from 1805 to 1835.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 134: (February 1845): 130–31.
States that the author is a fair and candid writer and that he presents facts with honesty and impartiality. Also states that the author is well suited to write about the subject. Reviewed: Wilson, Horace Hayman. The History of British India from 1805 to 1835. London: James Madden & co.
“Lays and Ballads, Chiefly from English History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 136: (April 1845): 266.
States that this work for children flows easily, has useful notes to illustrate the lays and ballads, and should have a place in any juvenile library. Reviewed: Small, S.M. Lays and Ballads, chiefly from English History. London: James Burns.
“On the History and Art of Warming and Ventilatio Rooms and Buildings, &c. &c.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 136: (April 1845): 266–67.
Judges that this work is too much history and not enough instruction on how to construct these spaces, but that it is well-researched and would be beneficial to physicians who need to direct temperature during cold season. Reviewed: Bernan, Walter. On the History and Art of Warming and Ventilatio Rooms and Buildings. London: George Bell.
“Maxwell’s History of the Irish Rebellion.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 137: (May 1845): 336.
Notes the number of useful illustrative plates in parts 14 and 15 of this work, including a full length portrait of Robert Emmett.
“Thiers’ History of France Under Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 137: (May 1845): 310–23.
Claims that this work is a clear and eloquent narrative, and that the author shows appreciation of personal character with respect to the leading actors in his history. Reviewed: Thiers, M.A. History of France Under Napoleon. vol. I & II. trans. D. Forbes Campbell. London: Colburn.
“The Punjaub.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 140: (August 1845): 534.
States that this account is plain and sensible but covers all the important topics. Reviewed: Steinbach, Lieutenant-Colonel. The Punjaub: being an Account of the Country of the Sikhs; its Extent, History, Commerce, Productions, Government, Manufactures, Laws, Religion. London: Smith, Elder, & co. See also May 1846.
“A Hand-Book of Spain; for Travellers in Spain, and Readers at Home: Describing the Country and Cities; the Natives and Their Manners; the Antiquities, Religion, Legends, Literature, Pine Arts, Sports, and Gastronomy; with Notices on Spanish History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 141: (September 1845): 610.
Judges that this work is comprehensive and its systematic and lucid arrangement prevent repetition. Reviewed: A Hand-Book of Spain; for Travellers in Spain, and Readers at home: describing the Country and Cities; the Natives and their Manners; the Antiquities, Religion, Legends, Literature, Pine Arts, Sports, and Gastronomy; with Notices on Spanish History. Part I & II. London: John Murray.
“A History of Ireland; Adapted for Schools, Youths, and Families.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 141: (September 1845): 611.
Notes that this work is impartial and useful to those who have the time for voluminous histories. Reviewed: Miss Corner. A History of Ireland; adapted for Schools, Youths, and Families. London: Deans & co.
“Thiers’ History of Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 141: (September 1845): 566–79.
Notes that this narrative is lively and has literary merit although it could upset British readers. Reviewed: Thiers, A. (former PM of France). History of France Under Napoleon. vol. II& III. trans. D. Forbes Campbell. London: Colburn.
“England and Its People.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 143: (November 1845): 744.
Judges this work one of the best histories of England. Reviewed: Taylor, Emily. England and its People; a Familiar History, for Young Persons, of the Country, and the Social and Domestic Manners of its Inhabitants, with Portraits and Illustrations. 2nd ed. London: Houlston & Stoneman.
“Memoir of George Heriot; with the History of the Hospital Founded by Him in Edinburgh, and an Account of the Heriot Foundation Schools.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 143: (November 1845): 734–35.
States that this work is interesting and entertaining but Steven has neglected to discuss how Heriot’s institutions benefitted society. Reviewed: Steven, William. Memoir of George Heriot; with the History of the Hospital founded by him in Edinburgh, and an Account of the Heriot Foundation Schools. Edinburgh: Bell & Bradfute.
“The History of the British Empire in India.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 12, no. 143: (November 1845): 740.
Notes that this work presents details with accuracy and amplitude, is well executed with good spirit and tone and is a fair and lucid narrative on a difficult subject. Reviewed: Thornton, Edward. The History of the British Empire in India. London: W.H. Allan & co.
“The Scottish Church; A View of Its History, Constitution, Doctrines, and Ceremonies.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 145: (January 1846): 56–57.
States that this work is carefully and cautiously written, is unbiased, and is clear, calm, and level in presenting explanatory statements. Reviewed: The Scottish Church; A View of its History, Constitution, Doctrines, and Ceremonies. ed. Alexander Leighton. Edinburgh: Wm Tait.
“Tytler’s Elements of General History, Ancient and Modern.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 146: (February 1846): 132.
This enlarged and improved edition uses the valuable original text and allows the spirit of the original text to shine through. Reviewed: Elements of General History, Ancient and Modern. Ed. Rev. Brandon Turner. London: Adam Scott.
“History of the Reformation of the Sixteenth Century.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 147: (March 1846): 198–99.
Review initially discusses the quarrel between publishers about who had the rights to publish this work in English, and then goes on to state that the new edition is better printed and is thus more expensive; judges the work to be interesting. Reviewed: D’Aubigne, J.H. Merle. History of the Reformation of the Sixteenth Century. 4th ed. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd. See also May and August 1846, and June 1853..
“Knight’s History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 147: (March 1846): 201.
Judges this work to be written in a liberal and enlightened spirit. Reviewed: Knight. History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace. part I..
“Essays on Subjects Connected with the Literature, Popular Superstitions, and History of England in the Middle Ages.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 148: (April 1846): 267.
States that this work will be admired, especially by those who study early literature or legend and lore of antiquity. Reviewed: Wright, Thomas. Essays on Subjects connected with the Literature, Popular Superstitions, and History of England in the Middle Ages. London: John Russell Smith.
“Sketches from Scripture History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 148: (April 1846): 263–64.
Reviewer discusses the character of the author and how this work came to be published, offers an overview of the content, and gives a few excerpts. Reviewed: Scott, William. Sketches from Scripture History. Blackwood & Sons.
“Oliver & Boyd’s Standard Edition of D’Aubigne’s History of the Reformation.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 149: (May 1846): 333.
Reviewer discusses only the issues associated with the rights to translate and publish this work. Reviewed: Oliver & Boyd’s Standard Edition of D’Aubigne’s History of the Reformation. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd. See also March and August 1846 and June 1853.
“Outlines of the History of France, for Families and Schools.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 151: (May 1846): 473.
‘This seems a well-digested, small compendium’ (the whole review). Reviewed: Cockayne, Rev. O. Outlines of the History of France, for Families and Schools. London: Parker.
“The Modern British Plutarch; or, Liver of Men Distinguished in the Recent History of Our Country for Their Talents, Virtues, or Achievements.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 149: (May 1846): 332.
Review observes that many lives are discussed, but not in minute or elaborate style; however this is acceptable since the book is intended for young readers. Reviewed: Taylor, W.C. The Modern British Plutarch; or, Lives of Men Distinguished in the Recent History of our Country for their Talents, Virtues, or Achievements. London: Grant & Griffith.
“The Punjaub; Being a Brief Account of the Country of the Sikhs, Its History, Extent, Commerce, Productions, &c.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 149: (May 1846): 333.
Reviews states that they reviewed this work last year (see August 1846) when the first edition came out and the review stands. Reviewed: Steinbach, Lieutenant Colonel. The Punjaub; being a Brief Account of the Country of the Sikhs, its History, Extent, Commerce, Productions. 2nd ed. London: Smith, Elder, & co.
“Grote’s History of Greece.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 150: (June 1846): 375–80.
Judges Grote excellent at selecting important historical information and discerning the cause of progress in the people. Also states that this work deals well with the mythical history of the Greek culture and overall shapes up to be one of the great philosophical histories. Reviewed: Grote, George. History of Greece. Part I Legendary Greece, Part II Grecian History in the reign of Peisistratus of Athens. London: Murray.
“History of the Panjab; and of the Rise, Progress, and Present Condition of the S Ct and Nation of the Sik.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 151: (July 1846): 468–71.
The review mainly focuses on the content of the work and offers excerpts. Does state that the work makes use of original and valuable sources. Reviewed: (Anon.). History of the Panjab; and of the Rise, Progress, and present condition of the [S ct] and Nation of the Sik. London: Allen & co.
“D’Aubigne’s History of the Reformation.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 152: (August 1846): 538.
Discusses copyright of the work and publication costs. (no review of the actual text itself). Reviewed: D’Aubigne. History of the Reformation. Oliver & Boyd. For reviews see March and May 1846. For a later volume see June 1853.
“The History of Egypt, from the Earliest Times till the Conquest of the Arabs, A. D. 640.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 153: (September 1846): 608.
States this work is full of useful facts and is an important contribution to the history of progress of society. Reviewed: Sharpe, Samuel. The History of Egypt, from the Earliest Times till the Conquest of the Arabs, A. D. 640. London: Moxon.
Burton, John Hill.“M’cullagh’s Industrial History of Free Nations.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 13, no. 154: (October 1846): 661–68.
Notes that this work is full of instruction and excellent examples and is written with aptitude, ability, and clear and temperate judgement. Reviewed: McCullagh, W. Industrial History of Free Nations. Considered in Relation to their Domestic Institutions and External Policy. London: Chapman & Hall. (Attribution: Wellesley Index).
“A Catholic History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 14, no. 157: (January 1847): 62.
Observes that although this is not a History of England in the traditional sense, it is an entertaining compilation of Monkish Chronicles that will be enjoyed by Catholic readers. Reviewed: MacCabe, William Bernard. A Catholic History of England. Part I: England as described by the Monkish Historians. London: Newby..
Johnston, Christian Isobel.“Florentine History, from the Earliest Authentic Records to the Accession of Ferdinand the Third, Grand Duke of Tuscany.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 14, no. 158: (February 1847): 135–36.
States that this work is instructive and entertaining and full of information (not all of which is relevant). Reviewed: Napier, Henry Edward. Florentine History, from the Earliest Authentic Records to the Accession of Ferdinand the Third, Grand Duke of Tuscany. London: Moxon.
Troup, George.“History of the Sikhs, Vols. 1 & 2.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 14, no. 161: (May 1847): 346–50.
States that although this work is hastily written it does have considerable value as no other history on the subject exists. Reviewed: McGregor, W.J. History of the Sikhs, Vols. 1 & 2. London: James Madden.
Troup, George.“A History of Rome, from the Earliest Times to the Death of Commodus, A.D. 192.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 14, no. 162: (June 1847): 419–20.
Scan is illegible. Reviewed: Schmitz, Leonard. A History of Rome, from the Earliest Times to the Death of Commodus, A.D. 192. London: Taylor & Harton..
Troup, George.“History of the Conquest of Peru.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 14, no. 167: (November 1847): 779–85.
States that this work is interesting, contains valuable information, is skillfully written, and the data was collected and analyzed with great care. The reviewer discusses much of the content in great detail and offers many useful excerpts. Reviewed: Prescott, William. History of the Conquest of Peru. London: Richard Bentley.
“Schomburck’s History of Barbadoes.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 15, no. 169: (January 1848): 43–49.
States that this work will prove to be useful to natives, statesman, scientists, and politicians. However the reviewer notes aspects of repetition and overlapping coverage. Reviewed: Schomburck, Sir Robert H. The History of Barbadoes: comprising a Geographical and Statistical Description of the Island: a Sketch of the Historical Events since the Settlement and an Account of its Geology and Natural Productions. London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longman. [1888?].
Troup, George.“A History of Servia and the Servian Revolution.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 15, no. 171: (March 1848): 198–200.
Scan is illegible. A History of Servia and the Servian Revolution. trans. Leopold Ranke. London: John Murray.
Troup, George.“Edda, or the Tales of a Grandmother: History of Denmark.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 15, no. 171: (March 1848): 194–98.
Scan is illegible.
Troup, George.“Woman’s History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 16, no. 181: (January 1849): 67.
States that this book will be useful and enjoyable for young women and women of the ‘high walks of life’, the class to which it is addressed. Reviewer does not discuss the content in much detail. Reviewed: ‘Gertrude,’ Women’s History. Glasgow: W.H. Ogilvie.
Troup, George.“Macaulay’s History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 16, no. 182: (February 1849): 84–101.
Judges the work to be well-written and manages very well the integration of integrating social and religious history with the usual political history. Reviewer states that the only real problem is that Macaulay tries so hard to be impartial and just that the work often comes off as cold and passionless. The work is cold but clear, unimpassioned but pleasing. Reviewed: Macaulay, Thomas Babington. History of England. London: Longman & co.
“The History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 17, no. 184: (April 1849): 265.
States that this work is fairly written, contains good illustrations and is valuable as a record of dates and facts. Reviewed: The History of England during the Thirty Years’ Peace. ed. Charles Knight & Miss [Harriet] Martineau. London: Charles Knight.
“Outlines of English History: Outlines of French History: Outlines of General Knowledge.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 16, no. 189: (September 1849): 601.
Notes that these works contain a vast amount of valuable and interesting knowledge and will be useful to teachers and parents of children in school. Reviewed: Ince, Henry. Outlines of English History: Outlines of French History: Outlines of General Knowledge. London: James Gilbert.
Troup, George.“Early Scottish History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 16, no. 190: (October 1849): [615]-622.
Reviewer discusses how the work came to be created and published, and then goes on to summarize the content and question the validity of some of its claims. Reviewed: Lord Lindsay. Early Scottish History: Lives of the Lindsays. London: John Murray.
Troup, George.“History of St. Andrews.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 16, no. 191: (November 1849): 750.
States that this work contains varied and interesting content, has well done plates, and is well arranged. Also notes that it will prove useful as a guide book to visiting tourists as well as a useful history book for the general public. Reviewed: Roger, Rev. Charles. History of St. Andrews. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.
Troup, George.“The History of the Puritans in England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 17, no. 193: (January 1850): 57.
States that this work is written in a ‘judicious and moderate spirit’ and that it will do well in making the origins of New England States better known. Reviewed: Prof. Stowell. The History of the Puritans in England. London and Edinburgh: Thomas Nelson.
Lushington, Franklin.“Personal History of Charles II.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 18, no. 210: (June 1851): 353–56.
Notes that, while interesting, this work is biased, carelessly written, and disorganized to an extent that would distract readers. Reviewed: Lyons, Rev. C.J. Personal History of Charles II, from his Landing in Scotland, June 23, 1650, till his Escape out of England, Oct. 15, 1651. Edinburgh: Stevenson.
Mansfield, Horatio.“The History of Adult Education.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 18, no. 214: (October 1851): 646.
Notes that this work is useful; ably and carefully compiled. Reviewed: Hudson, J.W. The History of Adult Education. London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longmans.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of British India.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 18, no. 216: (December 1851): 772.
A credit to the author’s abilities and research skills, this work offers much valuable information in a small space and is spiritedly written. Reviewed: MacFarlane, Charles. History of British India. London: Routledge and Co. 1852.
Mansfield, Horatio.“A History of the English Railway; Its Social Relations and Revelations.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 217: (January 1852): 57–59.
States that this work is well done like the previous works by Francis and is a testament to his abilities. Reviewed: Francis, John. A History of the English Railway; its Social Relations and Revelations. London: Longman and Co. 1851.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of the Consulate and the Empire of France under Napoleon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 218: (February 1852): 126.
States that this translation of a highly valuable work is much appreciated. Reviewed: Thiers, A. History of the Consulate and the Empire of France under Napoleon. vol. X and XI. London: Colburn.
“The Half Century. Its History, Political and Social.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 221: (May 1852): 312–13.
Notes that this work is valuable, well-researched and presented with care but often has a florid and overbearing style. Reviewed: Wiles, Washington. The Half Century. its History, Political and Social. London: C. Gilpin. 1852.
“The Lost Steamer: A History of the Amazon.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 222: (June 1852): 375–76.
States that this work contains no valuable information on the Amazon in its many pages and goes on to point out several of the specific problems with content. Reviewed: Knox, R. The Lost Steamer: a History of the Amazon. London: John Von Voorst.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of the Council of Trent.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 223: (July 1852): 444.
Notes that this translated work is comprehensive and complete; also a fine example of Edinburgh typography. Reviewed: Bungener, L.F. History of the Council of Trent. Edinburgh: Thomas Constable and Co., London: Hamilton, Adams, and Co. 1852.
Mansfield, Horatio.“Rhymes for Youthful Historians, on the History of England; Brought down to the Reign of Queen Victoria.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 223: (July 1852): 440.
States that this useful work arranges history into familiar couplets that will be easy for students to remember. Reviewed: Rhymes for Youthful Historians, on the History of England; brought down to the Reign of Queen Victoria. London: Wilson, Edinburgh: A. & C. Black, Dublin: J.M. Glashan.
“The Celt, the Roman, and the Saxon: A History of the Early Inhabitants of Britain, down to the Conversion of the Anglo-Saxons to Christianity.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 223: (July 1852): 446–47.
States that this work is valuable, contains a mass of information, has useful engravings, and will prove useful to young students. Reviewed: Wright, Thomas. The Celt, the Roman, and the Saxon: A History of the early Inhabitants of Britain, down to the Conversion of the Anglo-Saxons to Christianity. London: Arthur Hall. 1852.
Mansfield, Horatio.“Lives of the Sovereigns of Rassia, from Ru i to Nicholas; Including a History of That Empire, from Its Foundation to the Present Time.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 224: (August 1852): 504–5.
Notes that this work is entertaining and contains a mass of information. Reviewed: Fowler, George. Lives of the Sovereigns of Rassia, from Ru i to Nicholas; including a history of that Empire, from its foundation to the present time. vol. I. London: William Shubert.
“Our Iron Roads: Their History, Construction, and Social Influences.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 225: (September 1852): 572.
States this work is detailed, shows the labours that were taken in its creation; the engravings are really well done. Reviewed: Williams, Frederick S. Our Iron Roads: their History, Construction, and Social Influences. London: Ingram, Cooke & co.
“The History of the Painters of All Nations.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 225: (September 1852): 568.
Notes that this work has excellent engravings, is well-written and contains useful info. Reviewed: Blanc, M. Charles. The History of the Painters of All Nations. trans. Peter Berlyn. ed. M. Digby. London: John Cassell.
Mansfield, Horatio.“A Manual of Universal History: On the Basis of Ethnography.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 226: (October 1852): 635.
States this work is clear, polished, and valuable to both the learned and the learner. Reviewed: Wright, J.B. A Manual of Universal History: on the Basis of Ethnography. Bath: Binns and Goodman, London: Whittaker, Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd. 1852.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of the Jesuits: Their Origin, Progress, Doctrines and Designs.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 226: (October 1852): 634–35.
Announcement; no review as the editors are waiting until the concluding volume to make a critique but they expect it will be as well done as the author’s past works. Reviewed: Nicolini, G.B. History of the Jesuits: Their Origin, Progress, Doctrines and Designs. Edinburgh: J Nichol, London: J. Nisbet, 1852.
“Liturgy and Church History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 19, no. 226: (October 1852): 638.
States that this work will be useful to students and teachers and was created and put together with care. Reviewed: Bromby, Rev. C.H. Liturgy and Church History. London: Simpkin, Marshall, and co. 1852.
Mansfield, Horatio.“The History of Germany and the Austrian Empire; from the Earliest Period to the Present Time. Adapted for Youth, Schools, and Families.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 233: (May 1853): 313.
States that this work is compact yet comprehensive and contains all the necessary knowledge for a pupil learning dates and facts about German history. Reviewed: Miss [Julia] Corner. The History of Germany and the Austrian Empire; from the Earliest Period to the Present Time. Adapted for Youth, Schools, and Families. London: Thomas Dean and Son. 1853. (Book was first published 1841).
“Christ’s College, Brecon, Its Past History and Present Capabilities Considered, with Reference to a Bill Now before Parliament.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 234: (June 1853): 382.
States that this work is eloquent, well argued, and contains practical good sense. Reviewed: Christ’s College, Brecon, its Past History and Present Capabilities considered, with Reference to a Bill now before Parliament. London: Longman and co. 1853.
“History of the Reformation of the Sixteenth Century.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 234: (June 1853): 378–80.
States that this work is pleasant and readable; if the author stays true to himself this work will prove to be useful and well received. Reviewed: D’Aubigne, J.H. Merle. History of the Reformation of the Sixteenth Century. vol. V. trans. H. White. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd. Earlier volumes reviewed in 1846.
Agoult, Marie Catherine Sophie de Flavigny.“Gervinus, and His Introduction to the History of the Nineteenth Century.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 235: (July 1853): [385]-390.
Reviewer discusses the controversy over the creation and distribution of this work, offers a detailed account of its content. Also discusses unfortunate omissions, such as consideration of the economic and scientific state of European society. Reviewed: Gervinus, G.G. Introduction to the History of the Nineteenth Century. London: H.G. Bohn. 1853.
“History of Religious Intolerance in Spain, &c.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 235: (July 1853): 442.
States that although this work contains useful facts it suffers greatly from the compression of the material into a too-small space. Reviewed: de Castro, Don Alfonso. History of Religious Intolerance in Spain. trans Thomas Parker. London: W and F.G. Cush. 1853.
“History of the Byzantine Empire, from 716 to 1057.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 235: (July 1853): 443–44.
States that this work has a clear and vigorous style, makes use of many excellent sources, and presents good data in a well arranged fashion. Reviewed: Finlay, George. History of the Byzantine Empire, from 716 to 1057. London and Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons. 1853.
“History and Romance of Life Assurance.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 236: (August 1853): 456–63.
Reviewer mostly offers content and excerpts but does state that this work is interesting and useful, and offers detailed information on many important topics. Reviewed: Francis, John. Annals, Anecdotes, and Legend: A Chronicle of Life Assurance. London: Longman and Co. 1853.
“Rodwell’s Child’s First Step to the History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 238: (October 1853): 632.
States that this work contains excellent engravings and is simply written which is beneficial to its target audience of children. Reviewed: [Anne] Rodwell. Child’s First Step to the History of England. London: Hall, Virtue, and Co. 1853.
“The Panthropheon; or, History of Food and Its Preparation, from the Earliest Ages of the World.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 238: (October 1853): 637.
Announcement of a well-researched and interesting work , noting that space constraints prevent further discussion. Reviewed: Soyer, A. The Panthropheon; or, History of Food and its Preparation, from the Earliest Ages of the World. London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co. 1853.
“Outlines of Universal History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 20, no. 240: (December 1853): 759.
States that this small compendium is useful to the students for whom it is intended , and also for general readers. Reviewed: White, Henry. Outlines of Universal History. London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd. 1853.
“Turkey; or, a History of the Origin, Progress, and Decline of the Ottoman Empire.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 21, no. 244: (April 1854): 252.
States that this work is well put together, contains many useful and well-researched facts, and contains useful maps with excellent notes. Reviewed: Fowler, G. Turkey; or, a History of the Origin, Progress, and Decline of the Ottoman Empire.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History and Progress of the Temperance Reformation in Great Britain and Other Countries of the Globe, &c.; and a Plea for a Maine Law.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 21, no. 248: (August 1854): 503.
States that this work is written in a clear and masterly style and that facts not words are the argument. Reviewed: Buckingham, James Silk. History and Progress of the Temperance Reformation in Great Britain and other Countries of the Globe, &c.; and a Plea for a Maine Law. London: Partridge, Oakey, and Co. 1854.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of the Ottoman Empire, from the Earliest Period to the Present Time.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 21, no. 249: (September 1854): 569.
States that this work is a careful and conscientious summary of the most important events and is brief enough to be read by the general reader but is nevertheless detailed and comprehensive. Reviewed: Deans, William. History of the Ottoman Empire, from the Earliest Period to the Present Time. London and Edinburgh: Fullarton and Co. 1854.
Mansfield, Horatio.“Ince’s Outlines of English History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 21, no. 249: (September 1854): 570.
States that this work does what it promises, to give pupils an accurate knowledge of events in English history. Reviewed: Ince. Outlines of English History. London: Gilbert. 1854. new edition.
Mansfield, Horatio.“History of Scotland, from the Earliest Period to the Present Time.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 21, no. 250: (October 1854): 634.
States that this work is interesting, full of facts, impartial, and contains useful illustration; all the things a text book should be. Also states that it should have a place in every school library. Reviewed: History of Scotland, from the Earliest Period to the Present Time. ed. Henry White. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd, London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co. 1854.
“The Naval Heroes of Great Britain, Their History and Achievements.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1854): 754.
States that this biographical sketch of the most important sea captains is clever and acceptable. Reviewed: The Naval Heroes of Great Britain, their History and Achievements. London: Clarke and Beeton. 1854.
“Nineveh and Its Ruins: Or, the History of the Great City.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 22, no. 0: (January 1855): 61.
Claims that this work is a clever summary of interesting facts and does a great job of connecting the past with the excavated remains. Also states that the engravings are well done. Reviewed: Ferguson, Rev. Robert. Nineveh and its Ruins: or, the History of the Great City. London: Partridge, Oakey, and Co. 1855.
Mansfield, Horatio.“Wanderings in Corsica: Its History and Its Heroes.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (April 1855): 243–45.
Focuses mainly on the content of the work, providing several excerpts but does state that the translation is well done and offers an agreeable style for readers. Reviewed: Gregorovius, Ferdinand. Wanderings in Corsica: its History and its Heroes. trans. Alexander Muir. Edinburgh: Constable and Co.
“A Manual of Ancient History, from the Remotest Times to the Overthrow of the Western Empire, A.D. 476.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (August 1855): 506–7.
States that this work is a precise and beautiful presentation of history. Reviewed: Schmitz, Leonhard. A Manual of Ancient History, from the Remotest Times to the Overthrow of the Western Empire, A.D. 476. Edinburgh: E. and A. Black.
“Prescott’s History of the Reign of Philip II.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1855): 732–41.
States that this work offers a candid and discriminating examination of documents, is impartial, and has a clear and vigorous style. However its arrangement is not chronological and fragmentary. The reviewer spends much provides a detailed discussion of the content. Reviewed: Prescott. History of the Reign of Philip II. London: Bentley. See also January 1856.
“Macaulay’s History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 23, no. 0: (January 1856): 45–54.
Reviewer offers a summary of the content (if Volumes I and II) and many excerpts, noting that the work reads like a romance, contains good evidence, is well-written, and is overall a magnificent historical work. Reviewed: Macaulay. History of England. vol. III & IV. London: Longman and Co.
“Prescott’s History of the Reign of Philip II.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 23, no. 0: (January 1856): 29–37.
Continuing from December 1855, the reviewer reminds readers that this work is well done despite its fragmentary arrangement and focuses mostly on offering the reader an summary of the content. Reviewed: Prescott. History of the Reign of Philip II. London: Bentley.
“Macaulay’s History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (February 1856): 70–77.
This continuation of the review (covering volumes III and IV) reiterates that this work is written with a beautiful style, contains impartial and careful judgement, and has the evidence is both well-collected and well-used. The reviewer also points out some erroneous statements, but observes that for such a large work there are not many errors. Also points out that many groups have been angered by this work including the Whigs, the Tories and the Roman Catholics but states that this is to be expected when a truthful history is presented. Reviewed: Macaulay. History of England. vol. III & IV. London: Longman and Co.
“History and Conquests of the Saracens.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (July 1856): 448.
States that this set of six lectures presented at the Philosophical Institute of Edinburgh is an intelligent account of Mohammedan history and will be useful to all that are unfamiliar with the subject. Reviewed: Freeman, Edward A. History and Conquests of the Saracens. London: John Henry and James Parker.
“A Guide to Scripture History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (November 1856): 701–2.
Reviewer mainly discusses the content but also states that this work is valuable and contains interesting points although they are not always well proven. Reviewed: Rev. (Robert Kitton) Brewer. A Guide to Scripture History. London: Jarrold and Sons.
“A Half-Yearly Course of Reading Lessons in English History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (November 1856): 700–701.
States that this work needed to be concise and therefore the author had to be careful about what to omit; then goes on to complain about how Northern England is ignored and misrepresented and that the account of the Scottish people is misleading. Reviewed: Bithell, Richard. A Half-Yearly Course of Reading Lessons in English History. London: Groombridge and Sons.
“A History of Greece.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1856): 704.
States that this work is an asset to the library of anyone wanting a useful and in-depth look at the history of the people, politics and culture of Greece. Also states that the style of this work is simple, clear, and pure. Reviewed: Carr, Thomas Swinburne. A History of Greece. London: Longman and Co.
“Things Not Generally Known; or, Curiosities of History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 24, no. 0: (January 1857): 63.
Observes that the author collected information with great diligence and presented it with much skill. Reviewed: Tims, John. Things not generally Known; or, Curiosities of History. London: David Bogue.
“The History of the Factory Movement, by Alfred.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (November 1857): 699–701.
States that this work has brought into question important facts about labour and capital and warrants the author coming out of anonymity. Reviewed: [Samuel Kidd]. The History of the Factory Movement. London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co.
“A Compendium of Universal History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (November 1858): 694.
States that this work is useful , both to youths and to those who have long left school, with its question and answer form; it addresses very general facts about history. Reviewed: A Compendium of Universal History. London: Jarrold and Sons.
“Carlyle’s History of Frederick the Great.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1858): 743–48.
States that the first two volumes merely discuss the parents and ancestors of Frederick the Great, providing too much detailed information. Reviewed: Carlyle, T. . History of Frederick the Great. London: Chapman and Hall. vol. I & II.
“The History and Mystery of Common Things.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1858): 756.
States that this work is in question-and-answer form, providing information about various commodities such as what people eat, drink, wear. Reviewed: The History and Mystery of Common Things. Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
“Carlyle’s History of Frederick the Great.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 26, no. 0: (January 1859): 41–45.
Reviewer mainly offers a summary of the content of these volumes, with lengthy excerpts; also states that this work disappoints as it does not offer what is promised and has too many peculiarities of style. Reviewed: Carlyle, T. History of Frederick the Great. London: Chapman and Hall.
“French History.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (February 1859): 94–98.
Offers a summary of the content of this work with excerpts and states that it is interesting and told as a story which makes the reader forget they are even learning history. Reviewed: Miss [Julia] Pardoe. Episodes of French History. London: Hurst and Blackett.
“A School and College History of England.” Tait’s Edinburgh, 0, no. 0: (December 1859): 746.
States that this narrative is clear and concise, fair and impartial, and condenses a large amount of information clearly and intelligibly. Reviewed: Curtis, J. C. [John Charles] A School and College History of England. London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co.